DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23020015
Canonical: https://thonly.org/research/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time · Licence: CC0 1.0
This study reads the Buddhist debate on whether past and future things exist (the "three times") against the growing-block view of time that causal set theory's sequential-growth models are offered to support. Rafael Sorkin (2007) remarked that the "accretive time" of these models seems close to C.D. Broad's and to the "Vibhajavadin" school's; Fay Dowker (2022; revised 2023) invited a scholar to determine that school's view of time from the earliest records. The records, in Pāli, Sanskrit and Chinese, give no single view under the name. In the northern Abhidharma (Abhidharmakośabhāṣya ad V.25), the Vibhajyavādins hold that the present and past action whose fruit is not yet given exist, but not past action that has given its fruit, nor the future. That past thins, so the view resembles causal-set accretion only in keeping some past and denying the future; no position in the debate keeps every born element, as a growing block does. In the Pāli tradition, Vibhajjavāda is the Mahāvihāra's self-designation, and its Kathāvatthu refutes four rival views of time, among them, in its own words, the northern view's past half, held, its commentary says, by the Kassapikas (Kāśyapīyas). The Mahāvihāra holds presentism about conditioned phenomena, the view Sorkin offers his growth as an alternative to; nibbāna and concepts stand outside the three times. For physics it offers a contrast: past action conditions the present, and a past object is cognized, without either existing. On a second axis, the beginning, the Paṭṭhāna's proximity condition, as the commentaries draw it, gives a stream of mind no first member; bodies and world-regions begin. Classical sequential growth is past-finite; the one past-infinite growth study read (Bento, Dowker and Zalel 2022) builds a consistent covariant framework but offers no dynamics yet that grows a beginningless past in the physical order of its births. Seven findings are listed with their falsifiers.
Keywords: causal set theory, sequential growth, classical sequential growth, past-infinite causal sets, growing block, presentism, eternalism, philosophy of time, temporal becoming, beginningless time, beginningless saṃsāra, Buddhist philosophy, Buddhist philosophy of time, Abhidhamma, Abhidharma, Kathāvatthu, Paṭṭhāna, proximity condition, Abhidharmakośa, Sarvāstivāda, Kāśyapīya, Vibhajjavāda, Theravāda, Mahāvihāra, Vasumitra, Stcherbatsky, Broad, Sorkin, Dowker, Lean theorem prover, defensive publication.
The paper reads Pāli, Sanskrit and Chinese texts and places them against physics. An examiner or indexer searching in standard terms should find each concept under the term on the right.
| Term used here | Standard term |
|---|---|
| the three times; the three-times debate | the existence of past, present and future things; the debate among early Buddhist schools on eternalism and presentism |
| sabbam atthi; Sarvāstivāda (Pāli Sabbatthivāda) | "all exists": the school holding that past, present and future dharmas exist; a form of eternalism |
| Vibhajjavāda (Pāli), Vibhajyavāda (Sanskrit); Vibhajjavādin | "those who answer by distinguishing": a Buddhist school name; in the Pāli tradition the Theravāda's self-designation; in the Abhidharmakośabhāṣya, holders of the present plus unripened past action |
| Mahāvihāra; Tambapaṇṇiya | the Theravāda monastic lineage of Sri Lanka whose texts the Pāli canon preserves |
| Kassapika, Kassapiya (Pāli); Kāśyapīya (Sanskrit) | an early Buddhist school |
| Andhaka | early Buddhist schools of the Andhra region, so named by the Pāli commentary |
| Kathāvatthu | Points of Controversy: the fifth book of the Theravāda Abhidhamma Piṭaka, a book of doctrinal debates |
| Abhidharmakośabhāṣya (the Kośa) | Vasubandhu's treatise on Sarvāstivāda Abhidharma, with his own commentary |
| dhamma (Sanskrit dharma) | a momentary mental or material phenomenon; an element of existence |
| presentism about conditioned dhammas | the view that, of phenomena that arise from conditions, only present ones exist |
| kālavimutta (time-free) | outside past, present and future: in the Theravāda, nibbāna and concepts |
| Paṭṭhāna; paccaya | the seventh book of the Abhidhamma Piṭaka; a typed causal (conditioning) relation |
| proximity condition (anantara) | each mental state conditions the mental state immediately after it |
| kamma condition | conditioning of a result by a past volitional act, across moments |
| kammūpacaya | a persisting accumulation of past action (an opponent's doctrine in the Pāli commentary) |
| stream of mind; mind-stream (santāna) | the succession of one being's mental states |
| anamatagga; saṃsāra | without discoverable beginning; the round of rebirths |
| world-cycle (kappa); contraction | an aeon of Buddhist cosmology; its phase of destruction |
| sequential growth; classical sequential growth (CSG) | a stochastic dynamics in which a causal set grows by the birth of one element at a time (Rideout and Sorkin) |
| post; partial post; partial break | in causal set cosmology, an element related to every other element (a bounce); its local analogues (Dowker and Zalel) |
| alternating growth; alternating transitive percolation (ATP); Z-covtree | growth dynamics for past-infinite causal sets that alternate births into the past and the future; one such dynamics; a covariant framework for two-way growth (Bento, Dowker and Zalel) |
| discrete general covariance | label invariance of a causal-set growth dynamics: physical predictions do not depend on the order in which elements are born |
| growing block; accretion | the view that past and present exist and the future does not, so that the sum of what exists grows (Broad 1923) |
This paper is a study: it discloses readings of texts, not a mechanism. Its findings are listed here at the width that survived review and the census reported below, each with what would break it. The census's surviving width is a reading of the Kathāvatthu's time debates against Sorkin's and Dowker's causal-set remarks; findings 1–5 are parts of that reading and nothing wider. The historical identifications they rely on are prior art and are cited as such (Stcherbatsky 1923, p. 43 n.; Vasumitra; Cousins 2001). Findings 6 and 7 were added in the revision of 2026-09-30, after the census, which did not cover them; they assert no priority, since the derivation is the tradition's own and the physics is its authors' (§4.1–§4.2).
kala/Time.lean). MN 63's undeclared world is, in the commentaries, beings' aggregates asked about as permanent or annihilated, and a beginningless succession of impermanent states affirms neither (§4.1). Breaks if: a primary Theravāda source affirms, as its own view, a mental state arising with no proximity condition (a first citta of a stream, an uncaused ignorance); or a gap in a stream of mind is found that the tradition does not bridge by that condition.This document and its contents are dedicated to the public domain under the Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication, and are published so that they stand as prior art against any later attempt to enclose them. No patent has been or will be sought on anything disclosed in this paper by HeartBank®, Factory 333™, THonly™, Silicon Wat℠, or any entity under their common control, in any jurisdiction, at any time. The authors and those entities commit not to assert any patent right against any party practicing or teaching anything disclosed here. The commitment is stated rather than implied, is permanent, and is not conditioned on reciprocity, attribution, or field of use. A publication grants nothing and frees nothing already enclosed. Nothing here is claimed as a mechanism: the paper is a study, and what it discloses is the numbered list under Findings disclosed, with the readings in the body that support it. Trademark rights in the marks named here (HeartBank®, Factory 333™, THonly™, Silicon Wat℠, Miss Aquarius℠) are reserved separately and are not licensed by this publication.
Disclosed in the first version (2026-09-27): the two-referent reading of Sorkin's "Vibhajavadin", the placement of the Mahāvihāra's presentism as the foil of causal-set growth, and the contrast of influence without existence. The revision of 2026-09-28 corrected the placement of the Kośa's view (a past that thins, not a growing block; §9) and listed the findings; the revision of 2026-09-30 added §4.1–§4.3 and findings 6 and 7. The date of any passage is that of the earliest timestamped version carrying it.
What is already public, and cited rather than claimed:
abhidhamma-executable-process-specification), in this corpus, states that the mindstream is beginningless.The census. A quick novelty census ran on 2026-09-27. Its pre-registration was pushed publicly before any query: thonly/publications commit 7348ba2, timestamps/census/physics-lens-prereg.md. Its aperture was the English web, arXiv, Google Scholar, PhilPapers, GitHub and Google Patents by keyword. Thai, Burmese, Sinhala, Chinese, Japanese and Khmer sources were NOT RUN, and books were not read. Not found in that aperture on that date: a reading of the Kathāvatthu's time debates against Sorkin's and Dowker's causal-set remarks. The census also reported the two-referent answer as not found; that row is narrowed here, because Stcherbatsky's footnote, read after the census, already gives most of it. A census result is a statement about a search, not a claim of priority. The comparison of Buddhism with physics is a crowded field, and much of it is unindexed. Findings 6 and 7 were added after this census and were not searched; they claim no priority (see Findings disclosed). The growing-block literature on causal sets (Earman 2008; Arageorgis 2016) was found at the revision of 2026-10-06 and is cited above; it does not touch the reading the census reports.
Note. As first published on 2026-09-27 this paper stated that its authors and HeartBank® would not seek patent on anything in it ("The authors and HeartBank® will not seek patent on anything herein"); it carried no commitment not to assert. The commitment not to assert, and the extension of both commitments to the other entities named above, were added, and the statement brought to the standard form above, on 2026-10-06. The omission did not affect the paper's standing as prior art, which publication establishes; the date relied on is the one carried by this document's OpenTimestamps proof.
Causal set theory replaces the spacetime continuum with a locally finite partial order: discrete events, related only by before. Sorkin's slogan is order + number = geometry. In its sequential-growth ("classical sequential growth") models the causal set is not given all at once; it grows, one element at a time, each new element born to the future of some of those already present. Sorkin argued that this growth gives an objective correlate of the passage of time, a becoming that relativity was thought to have ruled out. His 2007 paper, "Relativity theory does not imply that the future already exists: a counterexample," makes the case. In §5 he describes what the growth yields as "something 'four dimensional' from the very beginning, but which at any stage of its growth is still incomplete", and he adds the footnote:
The notion of "accretive time" that arises here seems close to that of C.D. Broad, and also to that of the "Vibhajavadin" school within the Buddhist philosophical tradition.
Fay Dowker, developing Sorkin's proposal as a response to the hard problem of consciousness (arXiv 2209.07653), quotes the footnote and adds her own. In the revision of 21 May 2023 it reads:
A interesting project for a scholar of Buddhism interested in physics would be to try to determine the "Vibhajavadin" view of time, perception and epistemology in detail by examining the earliest existing records.
(The first version, of 16 September 2022, reads "would be to determine the 'Vibhajyavadin' view", without try to.)
For the Vibhajavādin view her notes point to p. 43 of Stcherbatsky's The Central Conception of Buddhism (1923). Separately, they cite his Buddhist Logic (vol. 1, 1932, pp. 4–5) for early Buddhism as "no Matter, no Substance, only separate elements, momentary flashes of efficient energy … a flow of existential moments."
The question is well posed, and it is answerable, because the records exist, in Pāli, Sanskrit and Chinese, and they are unusually explicit about time. What follows reads them.
Spelling note. Sorkin and Dowker's 2023 revision write Vibhajavadin; Dowker's 2022 version writes Vibhajyavadin. They are quoted as written. Pāli sources give Vibhajjavāda, Sanskrit sources Vibhajyavāda. The spellings mark traditions, and this paper keeps them apart deliberately.
The Kathāvatthu itself, the fifth book of the Abhidhamma Piṭaka, never uses the word. The self-designation is found in its commentary (Kathāvatthu-aṭṭhakathā, part of the Pañcappakaraṇa-aṭṭhakathā traditionally ascribed to Buddhaghosa, c. 5th century CE, drawing on older material). The commentary describes the Third Council under Aśoka: the king, having expelled monks of other views, asks the remaining monks what the Buddha taught.
"kiṃvādī, bhante, sammāsambuddho"ti? "Vibhajjavādī, mahārājā"ti.
"Of what doctrine, venerable sir, was the Fully Awakened One?" — "A Vibhajjavādin, great king." (
abh03a.att.xml:2181, aṭṭhakathā)
The elder Moggaliputtatissa then expounds the Kathāvatthu to refute the views that had arisen and those that would arise, setting out, the commentary says, a matrix the Buddha had laid down for the purpose (:2181; :1949). In the tradition's own account, therefore, the Kathāvatthu is the Vibhajjavādin record.
Cousins (2001) shows that the Pāli sub-commentators (the ṭīkā writers) know two related senses of the word: an epithet of the Buddha (one who answers by analysis, vibhajja) and the name of the Buddha's followers, specifically of their own school. Historically, he argues, it is the name for the viewpoint of the common ancestors of four schools: the Mahiṃsāsakas, the Dhammaguttikas (the commentary's form; Cousins's title writes Dhammaguttaka), the Kassapiyas and the Tambapaṇṇiyas, the last being the Mahāvihāra of Sri Lanka whose texts the Pāli canon preserves. The commentary's Third Council story, Cousins argues, draws its force from the double meaning. The present-day Theravāda is therefore one branch of the Vibhajjavādins, not the whole group. That matters below, because another branch reappears as an opponent.
The commentary's own family tree is different, and it is recorded here because it cuts against a tidy reading. Its schism narrative, which it supports with verses quoted from the Dīpavaṃsa, derives the Sabbatthivādins and the Dhammaguttikas from the Mahiṃsāsakas and then says: "Puna sabbatthivādakulato bhijjitvā kassapikā nāma jātā" ("again, breaking from the Sabbatthivāda family, those called Kassapikas arose"; abh03a.att.xml:1961). The Pāli commentary thus files the Kassapikas under the Sabbatthivāda, where Cousins places them among the Vibhajjavādin branches. The findings below depend on which school held the §299 thesis, not on which family tree is right.
[cross-tradition]The Sarvāstivāda's own systematization, as reported and criticized by Vasubandhu, defines the two camps sharply (Abhidharmakośabhāṣya ad V.25, Pradhan ed., p. 296, ll. 4–6):
ye hi sarvam astīti vadanti atītam anāgataṃ pratyutpannaṃ ca te sarvāstivādāḥ / ye tu kecid asti yat pratyutpannam adattaphalaṃ cātītaṃ karma kiñcin nāsti yad dattaphalam atītam anāgataṃ ceti vibhajya vadanti te vibhajyavādinaḥ /
Those who say that all exists, past, future and present, are Sarvāstivādins. Those who, distinguishing (vibhajya), say that something exists (the present, and past action that has not given its fruit) and something does not (past action that has given its fruit, and the future) are Vibhajyavādins.
(The text is GRETIL's, after Pradhan, with word division added; two typographical slips in the e-text, ye he and anāmataṃ, are given as ye hi and anāgataṃ.)
The Kośa's Vibhajyavādin, then, holds present plus some past, and no future. The name is glossed from the method: they speak distinguishing. The verse goes on to count four kinds of Sarvāstivādin, by how a dharma differs as it passes through the three times: in mode of being, in characteristic, in state, or in relation, the views reported (kila) of Dharmatrāta, Ghoṣaka, Vasumitra and Buddhadeva. The bhāṣya judges the third, Vasumitra's, the best, under which the times are fixed by a dharma's activity (kāritra): future before it acts, present while it acts, past once it has acted; it then presses objections against the Sarvāstivāda position as a whole (V.25d–26 and after, Pradhan pp. 296–297). The Vasumitra named there is a Sarvāstivāda master; this paper does not decide whether he is the doxographer of the same name cited below.
Stcherbatsky's p. 43, the page Dowker cites, describes the same school: an intermediate position that "maintained the reality of the present facts and of that part of the past ones which had not already lost their influence, but the reality of the future ones and of that part of the past ones which had ceased to exhibit any influence it denied. Vasubandhu calls this school the Vibhajyavādins." Dowker's pointer and the Kośa therefore agree. Stcherbatsky's footnote goes further. It reports that the Kathāvatthu (he cites "i, 8") ascribes such opinions to the Kāśyapīyas, who also admitted the reality of that part of the future which was foreshadowed or fixed; that, according to McGovern, Xuanzang's commentary identifies the Kośa's Vibhajyavādins as the Kāśyapīyas; that the Theravādins seem to have shared the Sautrāntika view; and that Vasubandhu seems not to know the explanation of vibhajyavāda as orthodoxy, the sense the Kathāvatthu commentary gives it.
Vasumitra's doxography of the schools, in Xuanzang's Chinese, gives the Kāśyapīya (飲光部) the same thesis on past action. Among its tenets: 若業果已熟則無。業果未熟則有 ("if the fruit of an action has ripened, it does not exist; if the fruit has not ripened, it exists"). Beside it stands a second criterion of the same shape: a dharma already abandoned and fully known does not exist, and one not yet abandoned and fully known does. The list adds that some formations have a past thing as their cause and none a future thing (無諸行以未來為因), and that all formations perish momentarily (一切行皆剎那滅). It states no thesis on whether future things exist.
The Kośa's definition is a Sarvāstivādin doxographer's report of an opponent (§10). Two northern reports, the Kośa and Vasumitra, agree on its past half (both from a Sarvāstivāda milieu, so not fully independent), and the Pāli debate book states the same past-half in its own words (§3).
The Kathāvatthu is a book of debates. The Theravādin (sakavādī) cross-examines an opponent (paravādī) by paired questions until the opponent's thesis yields a consequence he must reject. Four early debates, all in its first chapter, concern time. The Kathāvatthu names no opponents; the attributions below are the commentary's. Paragraph numbers follow the Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana edition, whose numbering of the debates differs from the one in common scholarly use: CST numbers the four debates 1.5, 1.6, 1.7 and 1.9, while SuttaCentral numbers them I.6, I.7, I.8 and I.10, and Stcherbatsky cites the third as "i, 8". The § numbers are unambiguous. An English translation with the attributions is Points of Controversy (1915).
| CST § | Debate | Opponent's thesis | Commentary's attribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| 282 | Sabbamatthītikathā | sabbam atthi: all exists | "seyyathāpi etarahi sabbamatthivādānaṃ" (the all-exists school, i.e. the Sarvāstivāda) |
| 297 | Atītakkhandhādikathā | past and future things are aggregates, bases and elements, and therefore exist | the paravādin who "wants past and future to exist because they do not give up being aggregates" |
| 299–300 | Ekaccaṃ atthītikathā | some of the past exists and some of the future (what is bound to arise). The restriction to action whose result has not ripened is in the Kathāvatthu's own text: "atītā avipakkavipākā dhammā – te atthi" | "seyyathāpi kassapikā" (the Kassapikas; one of Cousins's four Vibhajjavādin branches, though the commentary's schism list derives them from the Sabbatthivāda, §2.2) |
| 304 | Hevatthikathā | things exist in one way and not in another: the past exists as past | "seyyathāpi etarahi … andhakānaṃ" (the Andhakas) |
The refutations of all exists and some exists turn on one formula:
Atītaṃ atthīti? Āmantā. Nanu atītaṃ niruddhaṃ vigataṃ vipariṇataṃ atthaṅgataṃ abbhatthaṅgatanti? (§283)
"Does the past exist?" — "Yes." — "But has the past not ceased, departed, changed, set, gone down?"
The other two debates are refuted differently.
At §299 the Kassapika position is broken apart. If some of the past exists and some does not, then, the commentary explains, some of the past has ceased and some has not, which the opponent will not say; and the opponent grants that past action whose result has not ripened has ceased, so it cannot be said to exist (abh03m3.mul.xml:3345–:3365; abh03a.att.xml:3217). The same dilemma is run for the future at §300.
The position that remains, the Mahāvihāra's own, is presentism about conditioned dhammas: of conditioned phenomena only present ones exist; past and future are what was and what will be. The Abhidhamma adds a class that the three times do not cover. The root verse of Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha ch. 8 §37, summing up the states that serve as the twenty-four conditions, reads "tekālikā dhammā, kālamuttā ca", things of the three times and things free of time, and Sumaṅgala's sub-commentary names the time-free class: nibbāna and concepts (nibbānapaññattivasena kālavimuttā ca). Nibbāna is not a present dhamma; it is outside the question this debate asks.
WHAT EXISTS? past present future nearest physics picture
─────────────────────── ─────────── ──────────── ─────────── ─────────────────────────────
Sarvāstivāda all all all eternalism: a moving spotlight,
not a block (Miller 2017) †
Kośa's Vibhajyavāda [X] unripened all none a past that THINS; resembles
karma only Sorkin's only in keeping some
past and denying the future
Kassapika (Kv §299–300) unripened all what is (no clean analogue: a past
karma only bound to that thins, a future that
arise is partly settled)
Andhaka (Kv §304) "as past" all "as future" a tensed-property reading
Mahāvihāra (Kv, refuting none all none PRESENTISM about conditioned
all four) dhammas ◀── what Sorkin says
his model is NOT ‡
─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─ ─
Sorkin's growth every born no single none growing block (accretion)
(for comparison) element global "now"
No Buddhist row keeps every born element.
† Miller (2017) classes the Sarvāstivādins as eternalists and says explicitly that they are not
block-universe theorists; their view looks like a moving spotlight. Cited, not claimed.
‡ Of conditioned dhammas. Nibbāna and concepts are time-free (kālavimutta), outside all rows.
[X] cross-tradition (northern) source.
Sorkin's growth is not presentism. In the sequential-growth models, what has been born stays: the causal set at any stage contains its whole past and lacks only its future. Sorkin's own words set the view against a present-only doctrine. Most arguments for the block universe, he writes, "presuppose that the sole alternative to the 'block universe' is a doctrine that identifies reality with a three-dimensional instant". He also denies that the process has any single "now" spreading over it. Wüthrich and Callender (2017) examine what kind of becoming this is. They conclude that a novel, global becoming is compatible with causal sets, distinct from the localized becoming that the theory's advocates consider compatible with its dynamics. Nothing in that literature reads the model as presentist.
Whether the growth supports a growing-block metaphysics is itself disputed. Earman (2008, as quoted by Arageorgis) holds that the causal-set approach gives the growing block new life; Arageorgis (2016) argues that, mainly because of discrete general covariance, the program supports a growing block no better than relativity on a continuum does, and Sorkin himself writes that stopping the growth at a given stage "has no objective meaning within the theory". This paper's placement does not depend on that dispute. It uses only a feature of the models that neither side questions: a born element is never removed. "Growing block" in the map above names that feature, not a verdict on the metaphysics.
On the Buddhist map, then, no row is a growing block. The nearest is the Kośa's Vibhajyavādin, and only in two respects: it keeps some past, and it denies the future. Its past thins. An action ceases to exist once its fruit is given, and no other past dhamma is kept at all, where Sorkin's causal set keeps every element ever born. Sorkin's footnote points at a real resemblance in the school the northern sources describe, narrower than the word "close" suggests. It does not describe the school that uses the name today.
The map above has one axis: what exists. The Pāli texts and causal-set growth also differ on a second, which Sorkin's footnote did not raise: whether the order of what has happened has a first member. In the texts that order belongs to each stream of mind; there is no global one. This section and the next two were added in revision (2026-09-30).
What the texts say. The Anamatagga-saṃyutta (SN 15) opens:
Anamataggoyaṃ, bhikkhave, saṃsāro. Pubbā koṭi na paññāyati avijjānīvaraṇānaṃ sattānaṃ taṇhāsaṃyojanānaṃ sandhāvataṃ saṃsarataṃ. (SN 15.1; CST
s0302m.mul.xml:3489, mūla)"Without discoverable beginning, bhikkhus, is this wandering on. A first point is not discerned of beings hindered by ignorance and fettered by craving, running on and wandering."
The verb is epistemic. The commentary renders it "the prior limit is not seen" (purimamariyādā na dissati), glosses anamatagga as "with prior and later ends undelimited" (aparicchinnapubbāparakoṭiko), and reads the wandering as "the unbroken succession of the aggregates" (khandhādīnaṃ avicchinnappavattā paṭipāṭi; s0302a.att.xml:2489, aṭṭhakathā). That reading is the commentary's; the Kathāvatthu quotes SN 15.1 only as the Puggalavādin's proof-text for a transmigrating person (§75, abh03m3.mul.xml:849). SN 15.5's "not easy to count" concerns the years in one aeon, SN 15.7–15.8's the aeons past (s0302m.mul.xml:3529, :3553, :3565; the sibling paper, §5.3). The commentary ascribes the difficulty to the wandering's length (dīghatamattā) only as the questioning monk's reported thought (kira, s0302a.att.xml:2521).
What the texts leave undeclared. MN 63 leaves undeclared whether the world is eternal or not, finite or infinite ("sassato loko … anantavā loko", s0202m.mul.xml:1397, mūla). There, the commentaries say, the world is the world of beings (sattaloko; vin01a.att.xml:2169, s0516a.att.xml:881), and the Atthasālinī gives the predicates: the five aggregates held "permanent, stable, for all time" (nicco dhuvo sabbakāliko) or "cut off, perishing" (ucchijjati vinassati), and finite or infinite by the edge of a meditation device (kasiṇaparicchedantena), in space (abh01a.att.xml:9149). So the line runs by predicate, not by subject. A beginningless succession of impermanent states, any stream of which ends at an arahant's death, affirms neither permanence nor annihilation and says nothing of extent (an interpretation; §10). The predicate, not an unseen end, also separates it from DN 1's eternalist, whose self and world stand "like a peak" (kūṭaṭṭho, s0101m.mul.xml:283): the DN sub-commentary files even the fortuitous-origination view (below) under eternalism for seeing no end ahead (anāgate koṭiadassanato, s0101t.tik.xml:2061, ṭīkā).
From "not discerned" to "none", for mind. The Paṭṭhāna makes each earlier state a proximity condition of the next (abh03m7.mul.xml:85–:93, mūla), and its general statement confines the condition to mind:
Yesaṃ yesaṃ dhammānaṃ anantarā ye ye dhammā uppajjanti cittacetasikā dhammā, te te dhammā tesaṃ tesaṃ dhammānaṃ anantarapaccayena paccayo. (
abh03m7.mul.xml:97)"Whatever states, mind and mental factors, arise immediately after whatever states, those states are a condition by proximity for them."
Its negative method lists what arises not by proximity, and the rows it gives are all matter: mind-born, kamma-born at rebirth, the great elements, nutriment- and temperature-born, and the mindless beings' (:1201, referring to :1153–:1169; later chapters abbreviate or refer back). No mental state is listed there, not even a rebirth mind. That is the premise, a proximity predecessor for every mental state, which a first member of a stream of mind would lack. Conditionality in general would not suffice: fifteen of the twenty-four conditions are present-only (§6), and a mental state whose conditions were all co-nascent would be conditioned and still first. Matter differs. A body begins at each rebirth, and a world-region's matter begins again after a fire that burns until not an atom's worth of formation remains (Visuddhimagga XIII §405–406, e0102n.mul.xml:769–:773), that contracting world being the receptacle world (bhājanaloka, s0101t.tik.xml:1945). The claim is of streams of mind, and of beings' wandering because a mind-stream carries it; bodies and world-regions begin.
The step is the tradition's own. The commentary on MN 9 derives it from earlier ignorance conditioning later ignorance: "the beginninglessness of saṃsāra is established" (saṃsārassa anamataggatā sādhitā hoti, s0201a.att.xml:4309, aṭṭhakathā). The Visuddhimagga denies that ignorance is an uncaused root ("Na akāraṇaṃ", XVII §584, e0102n.mul.xml:3553), giving its cause from MN 9 ("with the arising of the taints, the arising of ignorance"), and in the same paragraph cites AN 10.61 (e0102n.mul.xml:3557): "a first point of ignorance is not discerned … and yet it is discerned: ignorance has this as its condition" (idappaccayā avijjā, s0404m3.mul.xml:1890, mūla). The Atthasālinī turns not discerned into none: no boundary exists, after so many hundreds of thousands of aeons or in some king's or buddha's time, before which beings were not ("ayaṃ paricchedo natthi", abh01a.att.xml:409). The aeons behind beings therefore exceed every count, not only every easy one. This paper reports the step; it does not claim it.
Two more statements of the step, and one parallel. (i) The Paṭṭhāna commentary states the join in a counting remark. Discussing which conditions fail to be found in the negative arrangement, it says of the mental ones: "for states arising by object condition and the like do not fail to get the proximity and contiguity conditions" (na hi ārammaṇapaccayādīhi uppajjamānā anantarasamanantarapaccayādayo na labhanti, abh03a.att.xml:9117, aṭṭhakathā). It is a remark about the conditions that sit in mind (arūpaṭṭhānika), which is the same confinement as above. (ii) The Samantapāsādikā sub-commentary, the Vajirabuddhi-ṭīkā, draws the step with a reductio, but only in passing. Its subject is Pārājika 3: it glosses "first" (paṭhamaṃ) in a verse on killing a parent as the rebirth-consciousness, the first consciousness of one life. It then adds, as a contrast, that in beginningless saṃsāra there is no first consciousness, since no consciousness arises without the proximity, contiguity, absence and disappearance conditions, and that a first one would incur the fault of a new being's appearing (aññathā anamatagge saṃsāre paṭhamacittaṃ nāma natthi vinā anantarasamanantaranatthivigatapaccayehi cittuppattiyā abhāvato. Bhāve vā navasattapātubhāvadosappasaṅgo, vin06t.nrf.xml:2177, ṭīkā). The Lean file does not reproduce the reductio, only the first ground (the conditions): a control run reproduces that ground in Lean from the premise as Visuddhimagga XVII states it. (iii) A parallel for the number of beings. The Buddhavaṃsa, in the Buddha's own account of his qualities, says that the four incalculables are those "whose limit is not discerned" (koṭi yesaṃ na nāyati): the mass of beings, space, the world-systems, and the Buddha's knowledge (s0511m.mul.xml:791–:799, mūla). The mūla says "endless" (anantakā) only of the world-systems. Of the mass of beings the commentary says "endless, immeasurable" (sattakāyo ananto aparimāṇo; s0511a.att.xml:2369, aṭṭhakathā). It is the same movement from not discerned to none as the Atthasālinī's, here made by the commentary for beings' number.
The view that holds the other option. DN 1 records a stream with a first member, to reject it. A being falls from the mindless deities (asaññasattā), recollects the arising of perception and nothing before it, and concludes "Ahañhi pubbe nāhosiṃ, somhi etarahi ahutvā santatāya pariṇato", "I was not before; now, not having been, I have come to be" (§67–68, s0101m.mul.xml:483–:487, mūla). The DN sub-commentary answers with the proximity condition: a mind long ceased "is merely a proximity condition, not the seed; the seed is kamma" (anantarapaccayamattaṃ hotiyeva, na bījaṃ, bījaṃ pana kammaṃ, s0101t.tik.xml:2057, ṭīkā). The same bridge spans emergence from cessation (abh03m7.mul.xml:5673) and death to rebirth across thousands of aeons (na kāladūratā, Kv anuṭīkā, abh05t.nrf.xml:2409). DN 27's re-evolving world starts a world, not a stream: its first beings fall from the Ābhassara heaven (s0103m.mul.xml:1105).
The step, checked. From the premise the step is short, and Lean 4 checks it (kala/Time.lean, theorem beginningless, in the CC0 repository SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma):
Conditioned s := ∀ m, ∃ p, succ p = some m every moment succeeds a moment of the same stream
tick_succ : succ m = some n → tick n = tick m + 1
──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
beginningless : Conditioned s → ¬ ∃ first, ∀ m, tick first ≤ tick m
Conditioned is the proximity premise for one stream of mind, not conditionality in general, and the content is the premise: replace it by True and the theorem fails (one of the file's deliberate breaks), while a model with a last moment and no first satisfies every axiom. For a presentist, "no first member" is a claim about what was (§3): a stream's has-beens have no first term; no infinite collection of past states exists now.
Page numbers are those of Bento, Dowker and Zalel (arXiv:2109.10749v1; published 2022), read in full, unless another paper is named.
Finite-past growth has a beginning "by definition of the model" (p. 3): in classical sequential growth no element is born to the past of an existing one, and "there are no past-infinite causets at all in the sample space" (p. 9). Read a stream's moments as a chain, as the sibling paper's relation S does (§3.3 there): a chain with no first member gives each member an infinite past, which no causal set in that sample space has.
Bounces, forward from a beginning. Transitive percolation (TP) almost surely grows infinitely many posts, elements related to every other (p. 15), each "a kind of collapse of the universe to zero diameter followed by a subsequent re-expansion" (Martín et al. 2001, p. 3); "TP realises the heuristic of a bouncing universe with a beginning" (p. 15). Collapse need not be global. Dowker and Zalel (2017, pp. 3–4) model a black hole birthing a universe beside an unrelated region by a partial post (an element y such that if y ≺ x and y is unrelated to z, then x is unrelated to z) or a partial break (A, B) (every element of A before every element of B, B a future set, A ∪ B a past set), and cosmic renormalisation follows. Dowker and Zalel (2023) model cycles by breaks as well as posts. All of this is past-finite.
Growth for past-infinite causal sets. Bento, Dowker and Zalel ask whether growth is compatible with a past without beginning; their process still starts "from the empty set" (p. 9), where the texts want no first stage. Four results bear on the texts.
They weigh both sides (p. 42): the difficulties with alternating growth and the covariance result "may be considered as evidence against the existence of physically meaningful dynamical growth models for two-way infinite causal sets"; "On the positive side", non-deterministic models suggest "that there may be models in which the convex-events may yet form a rich and interesting class of observables." A later overview still asks whether growth should produce "only those which are past-finite" (Zalel 2023, p. 2).
A world-cycle's contraction is not a post, nor a partial one. The texts' contraction is bounded: fire burns below the Ābhassara heaven, water below Subhakiṇha, wind below Vehapphala, and "one buddha-field is always what is destroyed" (sadāpi ekaṃ buddhakkhettaṃ vinassati, AN-a on AN 4.156, s0402a.att.xml:5988), 10¹² world-systems destroyed and re-formed together (Visuddhimagga XIII §404, e0102n.mul.xml:729–:733). Locality is therefore no contrast; Dowker and Zalel's partial posts and breaks are local too. The contrast is in who peoples the new world: beings "fall from the Ābhassara body and come to this state" (ābhassarakāyā cavitvā itthattaṃ āgacchanti, DN 27, s0103m.mul.xml:1105), the Ābhassara lying outside the fire's reach, and the DN sub-commentary adds beings from "world-systems other than the contracting ones" (saṃvaṭṭamānalokadhātūhi aññalokadhātūsu, s0101t.tik.xml:1945). Read as a causal set, with each stream a chain and the destroyed field related to nothing outside it, the new world's past runs through moments outside the collapse. It is not closed, as a partial break requires, and those moments precede the new world without being related to the collapse, as a partial post forbids. A contraction in the texts is neither a post nor a partial post or break.
THE BEGINNING: does the order of what has happened have a first member?
(for a causal set, its past; in the texts, each stream of mind, no global one)
┌─ a first member ─────────────────────┬─ no first member ──────────────────────┐
WHAT EXISTS │ │ │
every born element │ Classical sequential growth │ Alternating growth (Bento, Dowker & │
is kept │ (Rideout–Sorkin): grows from the │ Zalel): elements born to the PAST of │
(growing block) │ empty set; order of birth = │ existing ones; becoming given up │
│ physical order │ "(nearly if not entirely)" │
│ TP: posts = bounces WITH a │ ATP, the one covariant model: bounces │
│ beginning │ with NO beginning; deterministic │
│ Partial posts and breaks: │ Models (18): not deterministic, not │
│ local bounces (Dowker & Zalel) │ covariant │
│ │ Z-covtree: consistent, covariant; no │
│ │ dynamics chosen; a post not measurable │
├──────────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
only the present │ (a mind-stream with a first moment: │ MAHĀVIHĀRA: presentism about │
(presentism about │ the fortuitous-origination view, │ conditioned dhammas; each mental state │
conditioned dhammas) │ DN 1 §67–68, recorded to be │ arises after its proximity condition; │
│ rejected; Vism XVII §584: │ no stream of mind has a first member │
│ ignorance is not an uncaused root) │ (SN 15 · Paṭṭhāna · AN 10.61); bodies │
│ │ and world-regions begin │
│ │ ◀── no causal-set model offered │
└──────────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘
Nibbāna and concepts are time-free (kālavimutta) and sit outside both axes.
The Mahāvihāra's cell asks three things of a model: (1) each mental state arises after its proximity condition, and nothing past comes to be after the present, which is the order half of becoming in Sorkin's sense (the other half, that the born element "signifies that the event (of its birth) has already happened", p. 8, is the persistence §3 denies); (2) no stream of mind has a first member; (3) nothing past exists. No causal-set dynamics in the literature read holds all three, but (3) alone carries that verdict, since every causal set keeps its past (§4) and no one read here, this paper included (§6), builds a presentist one. The informative question is whether a model holds (1) and (2). Classical sequential growth holds (1) and not (2); alternating growth reaches (2) by giving up (1); on Z-covtree no dynamics has been chosen. On the beginning alone the question is open: a gap, not a finding against the physics.
The nearest counter to (1) is the Paṭṭhāna's post-nascence condition, from a later mental state to earlier-arisen matter (the sibling paper, §3.3). That matter arose first and still exists when conditioned, so the order of arising is untouched.
Dowker asked for "the Vibhajavadin view of time … by examining the earliest existing records." The records give a three-part answer.
The records also bear on a question the footnote did not ask, whether the past has a beginning (§4.1–§4.3). This is a historical answer about what the records say. It takes no position on which view of time is true.
If the Theravāda is not a growing block, is there anything in it for a causal-set physicist? There is one thing, and it is a contrast rather than a correspondence.
A presentist owes an account of how the past can matter if it does not exist. The Pāli Abhidhamma gives one. Its analysis of conditioning is the Paṭṭhāna, summarized in Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha ch. 8. The Abhidhammatthavibhāvinī-ṭīkā, Sumaṅgala's sub-commentary on the Saṅgaha (c. 12th century, a later layer than the Saṅgaha itself), states the temporal reach of every one of the twenty-four conditions. In the CST text, its comment on ch. 8, §37 sorts them so:
TEMPORAL REACH (Vibhāvinī on Saṅgaha ch. 8 §37) CONDITIONS COUNT
──────────────────────────────────────────────────── ───────────────────────────────────── ─────
past only (the moment just ceased) proximity, contiguity, repetition, 5
absence, disappearance
past or present (dvikālika) kamma 1
all three times (tikālika) object, predominance (object form), 3
decisive support
present only (paccuppannakālika) the other fifteen 15
────
24
time-free (kālavimutta; Saṅgaha §37 root verse) nibbāna, concepts (paññatti) — not a condition class
abh03a.att.xml:3225), and the debate exists to refute the opponent's doctrine. The ceased act is a condition by kamma across moments, not a thing kept.The Kathāvatthu adds the epistemological half of Dowker's question. At IX.6 (§559) an opponent holds that a consciousness whose object is past has no object; the commentary names the opponents the Uttarāpathakas and gives their reason, that since a past object does not exist, a mind that takes one must be objectless (abh03a.att.xml:4629). The Theravādin refutes this: a mind can turn toward the past, attend to it and aspire concerning it, so a past object is a genuine object even though it does not exist. Perception and memory reach what is not.
So the Theravāda's answer to "how does the past act?" is influence without existence: the past conditions the present, and is cognized by it, without being real now. Set beside a causal set, this is a contrast, and its use is that it locates the disagreement exactly. In causal sets the order relation, not a background time, carries the physics, and the order holds between elements that remain in the set; the past is kept. The Theravāda keeps the effects of conditioning and discards the past relatum; nothing persists to be related. The two agree that the past acts and disagree about whether it is there. A presentist causal set would be a different ontology from Sorkin's, and whether one is coherent is a question for physics, not for this paper.
Objection. "Presentism is a Western category, and the Abhidhamma is a phenomenology of experience. It is not a metaphysics of spacetime. Mapping atthi ('exists') onto the ontology of a causal set compares two different questions."
What survives it. Much of the objection stands, and the paper does not try to answer it away. The Kathāvatthu's atthi is about dhammas, momentary mental and material phenomena, not about spacetime points. Its debates are about what may be said to exist in a doctrinal register. And the Abhidhamma's momentariness has no metric: its moments carry no length in any physical unit (the texts name the mind-moment as a unit of reckoning and time nothing in seconds; abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity §5.2–§5.3), and its "present" is not a global simultaneity slice, which causal sets deny in any case. What survives is historical and exact: which positions on the existence of the past and the future were taken, by whom, and which the Pāli tradition rejected. Sorkin's footnote made a historical claim, and a historical claim can be checked against records. That, and placing the records against published models in §4.1–§4.3, is all this paper does with the physics.
The counter-argument to this paper's own strongest claim. Our strongest claim is that the Pāli Vibhajjavāda is Sorkin's foil. Against it, the provenance of Sorkin's word points away from the Pāli branch. Dowker's own pointer, Stcherbatsky p. 43, describes the Kośa's school, and Stcherbatsky's footnote reports, after McGovern, Xuanzang's commentary identifying that school with the Kāśyapīyas. So the referent of "Vibhajavadin" in the causal-set literature is the northern one by construction, and Sorkin's footnote is broadly right about the school it names. On this reading, a comparison with the Mahāvihāra changes the subject. We accept this. We claim only that the branch that preserved the Pāli canon, and uses the name today, holds the opposite view; that its record refutes the named school's past half; and that the resemblance even for the named school is partial (§4). Whether a reader of the footnote should have the Mahāvihāra in mind is a question about the word, and the records show why it is ambiguous.
The authors' stake. The authors write from within the Theravāda, and the institution publishing this paper grounds its values in the Pāli canon and has ruled Theravāda readings over Sarvāstivāda ones on its own questions. That creates a pull toward finding one's tradition anticipated by frontier physics. This paper's first draft of the thesis made exactly that error. It read the Pāli presentism as Sorkin's "becoming", on his side. An adversarial review, run before any prose was written, found that Sorkin's growth keeps the past, and the thesis was reversed. The reversal is the paper. A later review round corrected a second overreach of the same kind in the other direction: the first published text placed the Kośa's view at the growing block, which its own translation contradicts.
Done:
kala/Time.lean built with Lean 4.34.1 on 2026-09-30: seven theorems and the model check, and all six deliberate breaks fail as required;Not done:
kala/Time.lean is exploratory and outside the repository's pre-registration, and the two runs that record the reasoning (runs/2026-09-30-the-beginning, runs/2026-09-30-longest-chain) are retrospective and count for nothing as tests.Sorkin heard, in a school name, an echo of the time his models grow. The echo is real and partial. It comes from one school of a family, the one the northern sources describe, whose past is kept only while its fruit is owed. The branch that kept the Pāli canon answered that view in its canonical book of debates, with a question it asks of every past thing: has it not ceased? The answer to Dowker's invitation is that the earliest records disagree with each other on the existence of the past — the question on which, in a different register, the physics of becoming is still open. On a second question the Pāli records read here agree: no stream of mind has a first member, though bodies and world-regions begin. There the physics, in the one study read closely, has a consistent covariant frame for a past without beginning and no dynamics on it yet chosen.
| Venue | Identifier |
|---|---|
| Primary canonical | <https://thonly.org/research/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time> |
| GitHub | <https://github.com/thonly/publications/blob/main/defensive-publications/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time.md> |
| Zenodo (concept DOI, resolving to the latest version) | <https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23020015> |
| Internet Archive (the site, captured daily) | <https://web.archive.org/web/2026*/thonly.org/research/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time> |
| Software Heritage (the repository) | <https://archive.softwareheritage.org/browse/origin/?origin_url=https://github.com/thonly/publications> |
| Census pre-registration (public) | thonly/publications commit 7348ba2, timestamps/census/physics-lens-prereg.md |
Sibling paper (abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity) | <https://thonly.org/research/abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity> |
| Lean check of §4.1 (public, CC0) | <https://github.com/SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma> — kala/Time.lean, theorem beginningless; software concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23067241 |
| Independent timestamps | an OpenTimestamps proof anchored in Bitcoin, and RFC 3161 tokens from three timestamp authorities, one of them eIDAS-qualified; a timestamp proves that this exact text existed by its date and nothing about authorship, originality, or validity |
The authors thank Rafael Sorkin and Fay Dowker, whose footnotes asked a question the Pāli sources can answer; Bruno Valeixo Bento, Fay Dowker and Stav Zalel, whose study of past-infinite growth gave the second axis its physics; the Vipassana Research Institute for the Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana texts; the GRETIL project and the editors of its Abhidharmakośabhāṣya e-text (after Pradhan); the CBETA project for the Chinese canon; the Digital Library of India and the Internet Archive for Stcherbatsky's 1923 text; and the late L.S. Cousins. The reading of the sources, the adversarial review and the drafting were done with Miss Aquarius, the name under which this institution discloses its AI collaboration.
tipitaka-xml, romn/abh03m3.mul.xml (§282–§306; §559).romn/abh03a.att.xml.romn/abh07t.nrf.xml (bound with the Saṅgaha).romn/abh07t.nrf.xml.T49n2031.in.ernet.dli.2015.99616; Dowker cites a Motilal Banarsidass printing, dated 1922 in her reference list; the passage she points to is on p. 43 of the 1923 printing read here.)abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity). <https://thonly.org/research/abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity>.romn/s0302m.mul.xml:3489 (15.1), :3529 (15.5), :3553 (15.7), :3565 (15.8); its commentary, romn/s0302a.att.xml:2489, :2521.romn/s0202m.mul.xml:1397.romn/s0101m.mul.xml:283 (§31), :331 (§39), :483–:487 (§67–68); its sub-commentary (Sīlakkhandhavagga-ṭīkā), romn/s0101t.tik.xml:1945, :2057, :2061. Dīgha Nikāya 27, romn/s0103m.mul.xml:1105.romn/s0404m3.mul.xml:1890; the commentary on AN 4.156, romn/s0402a.att.xml:5988.romn/abh03m7.mul.xml:85–:97 (proximity), :1153–:1201 (negative method), :5673 (emergence from cessation). Kathāvatthu §75, romn/abh03m3.mul.xml:849.romn/e0102n.mul.xml:729–:773, :3553.romn/abh05t.nrf.xml:2409.SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma, kala/Time.lean. Software concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23067241. CC0.abhidhamma-executable-process-specification). <https://thonly.org/research/abhidhamma-executable-process-specification>.romn/s0201a.att.xml:4309; Atthasālinī, romn/abh01a.att.xml:409 (Nidānakathā), :9149; Samantapāsādikā, romn/vin01a.att.xml:2169; Cūḷaniddesa-aṭṭhakathā, romn/s0516a.att.xml:881.romn/abh03a.att.xml:9117; Samantapāsādikā sub-commentary (Vajirabuddhi-ṭīkā), CST romn/vin06t.nrf.xml:2177; Buddhavaṃsa, CST romn/s0511m.mul.xml:791–:799, and its commentary, romn/s0511a.att.xml:2369. Each line was read ±15 lines and the quoted words checked against the CST text on 2026-11-03.Each record below was opened on 2026-10-06 before the work was cited or kept, unless it is marked otherwise. Where a record lacked a detail the text uses, the detail was taken from the publisher's metadata as registered with Crossref that day, and is marked so.
T/T49/T49n2031.xml), the Kāśyapīya section in full.tipitaka-xml, romn/, commit 05d5d3c) through a local reader of that text, each with the lines around it: Kathāvatthu §75, §282–§283, §296–§300, §304–§305 and §559–§560; its commentary on §282, §297–§299 (with the kammūpacaya gloss, abh03a.att.xml:3225), §304 and §559–§561, its Third Council account (:1949, :2181) and its schism list with the Dīpavaṃsa verses it quotes (:1961); the Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha, ch. 8 §17 and the §37 verse, and the Vibhāvinī on §37 (abh07t.nrf.xml:6793); and every passage cited in §4.1–§4.2 (citations 24–30 and 33), with the Visuddhimagga's AN 10.61 citation located at e0102n.mul.xml:3557.