Discreteness, Adjacency and Order: A Structural Comparison of the Theravāda Abhidhamma with Causal Sets and Loop Quantum Gravity

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23020020

Canonical: https://thonly.org/research/abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity · Licence: CC0 1.0

Abstract

This study compares the Theravāda Buddhist Abhidhamma with two discrete approaches to quantum gravity, causal set theory and loop quantum gravity, as formal structures, on three axes: order, adjacency and ratio. It is a lens and not a physics claim. No row predicts a measurement, and none says that a Buddhist text anticipated a theory of quantum gravity. Each row gives a primer of the physics, the Abhidhamma material with its textual layer named, the correspondence, and where it breaks. On order, the twenty-four conditioning relations of the Paṭṭhāna, taken whole, are not a partial order. The condition-modes that always run from earlier-arising to later-arising form an acyclic typed relation over which a strict order can be read: acyclic by selection, not yet a causal set, and ordering some moments of different mental streams, which share no clock. On adjacency, the strongest row, a spin-network link is the face two neighboring grains of space share and carries a quantized area, while a Theravāda sub-commentary defines space as the non-mixing of touching neighboring material clusters (kalāpa). Both put the unit of spatial boundary at the adjacency between minimal units, and neither makes it one of the units. The features specific to loop quantum gravity, a quantized magnitude and a volume derived from it, are the ones that fail, and the shape that holds is generic to any cellular picture. On ratio, most material phenomena last seventeen mind-moments in the commentary and the manual, and only the generic part survives: a duration stated as a count of steps. A per-kalāpa count taken as the same in every frame would conflict with muon time dilation, but the texts state no such count. Continuity, magnitude and number fall among designations for mind and matter alike on one reported method of the teachers, and the rows about mind alone constrain no matter. The one textual size for a kalāpa, read as a metric size and carried to external matter, collides with nuclear structure by count and by size; Ledi Sayadaw's reading of the same line escapes the collision and leaves matter no grain of extent. A fifth row, the conditioned as a whole against quantum causal histories, was dropped for a stated reason. Two last findings set time and space against both programs together. On time, the match is a shared negative (neither program takes time as basic, on the readings cited): it does not separate loop quantum gravity from causal sets, and neither takes a per-stream succession as basic. On space, a causal set has no relation among elements that are not causally related, so the adjacency row's question, what lies between neighbors present together, cannot be put to it. Each finding carries its falsifier.

Keywords: causal set theory, loop quantum gravity, spin networks, area spectrum, quanta of space, partial order, Hasse diagram, discrete spacetime, relational space, Buddhism and physics, Buddhist philosophy of space, Abhidhamma, Paṭṭhāna, kalāpa, paricchedarūpa, ākāsadhātu, Theravāda, Abhidharmakośa, momentariness, asaññasatta, time dilation, muon lifetime, cosmic time, nuclear scattering, Rutherford scattering, proton radius, Z boson width, preorder, Lean 4, formal verification.


Terms

The paper uses Pāli technical vocabulary because it reads Pāli texts. An indexer searching in standard terms should find each concept under the term in the middle column. The layers in the right-hand column are the textual layers set out under How to Read This Paper.

Term as the tradition writes itStandard term used in this paperLayer where it is defined
S (this paper's notation)the acyclic sub-relation formed by the condition-modes that always run from earlier-arising to later-arising (§3.3)this paper's analysis
paccaya; Paṭṭhānacondition; the canonical treatise on the 24 conditioning relationscanon (summarised in the manual, ch. 8)
anantara, samanantaraproximity, contiguity (immediate succession of mind-moments)canon
āsevanarepetitioncanon
natthi, vigataabsence, disappearancecanon
sahajātaco-nascence (arising together)canon
aññamaññamutualitycanon
purejātapre-nascence (the condition arose earlier and still exists)canon
pacchājātapost-nascence (the condition arises later than what it supports)canon
sahajāta-, purejāta-, pacchājāta- modes of nissaya, indriya, vippayutta, atthi, avigatathe co-nascent, pre-nascent and post-nascent modes (sub-types) of support, faculty, dissociation, presence and non-disappearancecanon (e.g. Paṭṭhāna: atthipaccayena paccayo – sahajātaṃ, purejātaṃ …); grouped in the manual, ch. 8
kamma (nānākkhaṇika)volitional action (across different moments)canon (Paṭṭhāna, e.g. Kusalattika §427: nānākkhaṇikā – kusalā cetanā vipākānaṃ khandhānaṃ …); the time classification is sub-commentarial
ārammaṇaobject conditioncanon
upanissaya, pakatūpanissayadecisive support; natural decisive supportcanon
citta, cittakkhaṇaa moment of consciousness; a mind-momentcanon; the durations are commentarial
uppāda, ṭhiti, bhaṅgaarising, presence, dissolution (the three sub-moments)commentary and manual
rūpa-kalāpasmallest material clustercommentary; systematised in the manual
suddhaṭṭhakathe "pure octad" (four great elements, colour, odour, taste, nutritive essence)commentary and manual
ākāsadhātuthe space elementcanon
paricchedarūpadelimiting matter (space as the delimitation of material clusters)manual and sub-commentary
paricchedākāsa; kasiṇugghāṭimākāsa; ajaṭākāsa (also nijjaṭākāsa)delimiting space; the space left by removing a meditation disk; unentangled (open) spacecommentary (Kathāvatthu commentary; Atthasālinī)
paññatticoncept, designation (as opposed to an ultimately real phenomenon)commentary; manual
anipphannanot concretely produced; having no intrinsic nature of its owncommentary (Visuddhimagga, Sammohavinodanī); manual
padaṭṭhānaproximate causecommentary
paramāṇuthe smallest unit on the commentarial size ladder; given as the kalāpa's size by one sub-commentary, and declined by Ledi Sayadaw (§4.2)commentary; sub-commentary; modern exegesis
upanidhāpaññatti, upanikkhittapaññatti, santatipaññattidesignation by relation (long, short, far, near); by placing in series (two, three, four); by continuity ("eighty years old")the teachers' method, reported in the commentary (§2)
kālavimuttafree of time (said of nibbāna and concepts)manual; glossed in the sub-commentary
saṅkhāra, saṅkhata, asaṅkhatathe conditioned; conditioned; unconditionedcanon
sampayutta; ekuppādanirodhaconjoined (mind with its mental factors); one in arising and ceasingcanon; the formula is the manual's (ch. 2 §1)
asaññasatta, asaññābhavanon-percipient (mindless) beings; non-percipient existence, of one aggregate (matter) onlycanon (DN 1; Vibhaṅga; Dhātukathā; Kathāvatthu III.11); commentary; manual
indriyabaddha, anindriyabaddhabound to faculties (in a living body); bound to no beingcommentary (Atthasālinī)
utusamuṭṭhāna rūpatemperature-born matter, produced by the fire element inside and outside beingsmanual (ch. 6)
kappaaeon, world-cyclecanon (SN 15)
accharāsaṅghāta; mattāa finger-snap; a mora (the time of a short vowel)commentary; grammar
santati, santānaseries, continuity (of material or mental phenomena)commentary
saṇṭhānashape (had by matter, lacked by mind)commentary (Paṭṭhāna); sub-commentary

Findings disclosed

This paper is a study. It discloses no mechanism, so it carries findings and not claims. Each finding is stated in its surviving form, after the scope repairs of the 2026-09-28 and 2026-09-30 revisions and the additions of the 2026-11-03 and 2026-11-14 revisions, with its break beside it. The falsifiers are collected in §10.

  1. Order (§3.3–§3.4). The Paṭṭhāna's twenty-four conditions, taken whole, are not a partial order: mutuality makes 2-cycles, co-nascence relates what a causal order leaves unrelated, post-nascence runs from later to earlier, and the object condition reaches the future and the time-free. The condition-modes that always run from earlier-arising to later-arising form a relation S (proximity, contiguity, repetition, absence, disappearance, pre-nascence, kamma across moments, and the pre-nascent modes of support, faculty, dissociation, presence and non-disappearance), over which a strict order can be read. S also orders moments of different streams, with no shared clock, through kamma-born colour seen by another stream; mind-born colour gives a second route through a co-nascent edge outside S, and that route too is strict. Break: S is acyclic because it was selected by an index of arising time; its closure, and every cross-stream composition, is the reader's; local finiteness is unexamined; and S alone conditions no arising. So S is not a causal set.
  2. Adjacency (§4.5, narrowed by §9). Loop quantum gravity and the Theravāda sub-commentary both put the unit of spatial boundary at the adjacency between minimal units, and neither makes that boundary one of the units. On what is between minimal units?, the Vibhāvinī's answer (a named, counted item of the material list, though not an ultimate reality) has the shape of loop quantum gravity's (a link), not the Kashmiri Sarvāstivāda's (nothing). The tradition gives its own reason why the between is matter's alone: mind has no shape. Break: the parts of the match specific to loop quantum gravity (a quantised magnitude on the boundary, volume derived from it) are the parts that fail. The dependence runs in opposite directions; the link is incident to both grains, the delimiter touched by neither; the delimiter has no magnitude and is not an ultimate reality; kalāpas are matter in space, nodes quanta of space; the canonical space element is a cavity. The shape that holds is also held by any cellular picture and by the "neither" view of boundaries (§9), and the matter–mind asymmetry is the chain-against-antichain shape.
  3. Ratio (§5.3, narrowed by §9). Material phenomena other than the two intimations and the characteristics last seventeen mind-moments (fifty-one sub-moments) in the commentary and the manual; the tradition also records sixteen and a third, and sixteen (§5.2). Where a stream is present, the commentary dates its mind-born and kamma-born matter on its own mind-moments without making mind that matter's condition. Where none is present, no text counts matter in mind-moments: the mindless beings' material series is timed by kamma's momentum in aeons, and a sub-commentary makes the mind-moment a unit. What survives of the comparison is generic: a duration is a count of steps. Break: every discrete clock shares that much; the longest chain and the statistics fail, and whether a stream's order makes its time is left open (§3.4). A per-kalāpa count taken as the same in every frame would conflict with muon time dilation, but the texts state none, and let a series' duration vary (§5.4). The aeon meets the mind-moment only as divergence.
  4. The dropped row (§6). Saṅkhāra (the conditioned as a whole) set against quantum causal histories adds no structure beyond findings 1–3, and it maps a category that contains mind onto a structure that contains none. Break: the row would return if a structural feature of quantum causal histories were shown to have a Paṭṭhāna counterpart not already in findings 1–3.
  5. The scale of the mind-moment (§5.2). The texts name the finger-snap, the unit of their rate of mind, by a gesture and, in a grammar, as a mora or an eye-blink, without giving it a duration. They state the rate as round lower bounds in four works, of 10¹², 10¹⁰ and 10⁷ mind-moments per snap or more, and as a heap of rice grains; none states a ceiling. Break: any figure in seconds is the reader's conversion. The texts deny discernment of the succession to the reasoner and to "others", not to the wise or the Buddha. A text giving the snap a duration, or the rate an upper bound, would change this finding.
  6. The status of continuity (§2). On the teachers' method reported in the Puggalapaññatti commentary, relative length and distance, number, shape and continuity-age are designations on the unreal side, for mind and matter alike. The rows of the formal model that concern mind alone constrain no matter; matter's temporal discreteness enters only through the rows that state it. Santati, where each mind-moment has an immediate successor, is the gaplessness of a discrete series and not a continuum. So the texts settle the status of continuum-talk, and not the structure of matter. Break: the method is reported as the teachers', not the canon's; individuated dhammas stay real; the no-constraint result holds by the model's signature; the density argument covers the mental stream only, since a sub-commentary denies proximity to matter.
  7. The grain's count and size (§4.2, §4.8). The tradition has its own bridge from time to count to size: a sub-commentary on the Abhidhammāvatāra gives forty-nine kalāpas from a seventeen-moment life and three sub-moments, beside a measure bounded by the paramāṇu. The count follows from time, and the size does not. The Visuddhimagga Mahāṭīkā's "those kalāpas are of paramāṇu size", read as the metric size of one kalāpa and carried to external matter, collides with nuclear structure by count and by size on every anchor tried. Ledi Sayadaw reads the line as conformity with the powder meditation; his bound gives one kalāpa no lower size, and no grain of extent for matter follows. Break: the anchor, the carrying outward and the nucleon's place in the count are this paper's; every textual size concerns bodily matter; the line is a purpose clause in a meditation instruction, and a second reading in Ledi takes it of an accumulated measure.
  8. A conditional bound on the sub-moment (§5.4). If the Z boson were a series (santati) of pure octads, which is this paper's supposition, its measured width would put one sub-moment at or below about 2.6 × 10⁻²⁵ seconds. Break: the supposition is in no text; it gives an upper bound only, with no floor; a stronger bound of fifty-one times, tried in the source run, does not follow from the same premises.
  9. Time and succession against both programs (§5.4, §9). The texts make time (kāla) a concept designated on the occurrence of phenomena, and the occurrences it is designated on come one at a time in a stream [S, commentary]. A causal set has no time apart from its order, and loop quantum gravity, on Rovelli's covariant reading, takes no time variable as basic [X, physics]. So the match is a negative shared by both programs: it does not separate loop quantum gravity from causal sets, and "loop quantum gravity is the nearer on time" is not claimed. Neither program takes a per-stream succession, with immediate successors, as basic. Graded as an extension of the reading with the programs named, never as agreement, since neither is tested on this. Break: the negative is one reading of one wing of an untested program, disputed inside it; a formulation of either program with a worldline's succession as a primitive would withdraw the second half; the texts' "each moment conditions its immediate successor" holds for every moment but an arahant's last; and whether the succession is itself primitive is the question §3.4 leaves open, and is not decided here.
  10. Space against causal sets (§9). In a causal set, "spacelike simply means unrelated" (§3.1) [X]: no relation holds among elements that are not causally related, at any separation, and any spatial structure is derived from the relations each element bears to others outside that set. The Vibhāvinī's delimiter lies between neighboring kalāpas present together [S, sub-commentary], which §4.5 reads as an antichain. The adjacency row's question, what lies between such neighbors, presupposes a relation among them that a causal set lacks, so the row has no causal-set counterpart and §4.4's table takes no causal-set row. What the two share is the generic negative that space is not basic, on opposite bases: matter for the texts, order with no matter for the causal set. Graded as an extension with causal set theory named. Break: a causal-set formulation with a primitive relation among spacelike elements would remove it; adding co-presence meets the frame-dependence of co-presence, a difficulty this paper does not take up, and a theorem of Bombelli, Henson and Sorkin bears on structure built from a sprinkling, with whether an added primitive escapes it left to a physics reader; and spatial distance is already derived from causal relations by other means (Rideout and Wallden).

Prior-Art and Non-Assertion Statement

This document and its contents are dedicated to the public domain under the Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication, and are published so that they stand as prior art against any later attempt to enclose them. No patent has been or will be sought on anything disclosed in this paper — findings, structural comparisons, tables, diagrams or formal model — by HeartBank®, Factory 333™, THonly™, Silicon Wat℠, or any entity under their common control, in any jurisdiction, at any time. The authors and those entities commit not to assert any patent right against any party practicing or teaching anything disclosed here. The commitment is stated rather than implied, is permanent, and is not conditioned on reciprocity, attribution, or field of use. A publication grants nothing and frees nothing already enclosed. Nothing here is claimed as a mechanism: the paper is a study, its findings are the numbered list under Findings disclosed, each with its break stated beside it, and the comparisons, tables and diagrams of the body are disclosed as an analysis, not as a specification. Trademark rights in the marks named here (HeartBank®, Factory 333™, THonly™, Silicon Wat℠, Miss Aquarius℠) are reserved separately and are not licensed by this publication.

What is already public, and cited rather than claimed:

The census. A quick novelty census ran on 2026-09-27. Its pre-registration was pushed publicly before any query was made: thonly/publications commit 7348ba2, timestamps/census/physics-lens-prereg.md. The search covered the English web (including dharma sites and popular Buddhism-and-physics writing), and arXiv, Google Scholar, PhilPapers, GitHub and Google Patents by keyword. Thai, Burmese, Sinhala, Chinese, Japanese and Khmer sources were not run, and no books were read. The pre-registered control, the known comparison The Ephemeral Projector, was found.

ConjunctFoundVerdict
(a) the Paṭṭhāna's typed conditions against causal-set ordera general causal-set–Abhidhamma resonance (the AI-generated post; names no Paṭṭhāna condition)narrowed at general width; the typed-relation comparison was not found
(b) kalāpa against spin-network nodeskalāpas compared with atoms, quanta and the Planck length in popular writingnarrowed at "smallest unit" width; the spin-network-specific comparison was not found
(c) paricchedarūpa (space as the between) against area on spin-network linksthe commentarial reading of space as delimitation is public; no comparison with loop quantum gravitynot found in that aperture on that date
(d) saṅkhāra against quantum causal histories—not found; dropped before drafting (§6)
(e) the 17-moment lifetime as a discrete-time ratioSorkin and Dowker link causal-set becoming to Buddhist momentarinessnarrowed at general width; the chain-length reading of the ratio was not found
the composition of rows in one structural map—not found in that aperture on that date

"Not found in that aperture on that date" is a statement about a search. It is not a claim of priority, and nothing in this paper is offered as new. As a study that makes no priority claim, this paper owes no further census before deposit (ruled 2026-09-28); a literature census could narrow or kill the rows above, and would be reported here as a revision.

Note. As first published on 2026-09-27 this paper carried the CC0 dedication and the statement that its authors and HeartBank® would not seek patent on anything in it; it carried no commitment not to assert. The commitment not to assert, and the extension of both commitments to the other entities named above, were added, and the statement brought to the standard form above, on 2026-10-06. The omission did not affect the paper's standing as prior art, which publication establishes; the date relied on is the one carried by this document's OpenTimestamps proof.


How to Read This Paper

This paper is written so that a reader who knows calculus, but no linear algebra, quantum mechanics or general relativity, can follow every step. Each physics section opens with a subsection marked Physics primer, which builds the idea from nothing. A reader who already knows the physics can skip those subsections. Everything else is written for the exhaustive reader: the Pāli is quoted, the textual layer of every Abhidhamma claim is named in words, and every correspondence ends with the place where it fails.

Formulas are written in plain Unicode. Display formulas sit in monospace blocks. Where a formula is quoted, the source that derives it is cited.

Four textual layers are kept apart throughout, with a grammar and a modern exegete used for single points. They are named in words at each use, and every Pāli passage added in the 2026-09-30, 2026-10-06 and 2026-11-03 revisions is cited by its Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana file and line (for example abh07t.nrf.xml:1485) in the VRI tipitaka-xml text at commit 05d5d3c:

LayerTexts used hereDate (traditional or scholarly)
canonDhammasaṅgaṇī, Vibhaṅga, Dhātukathā, Kathāvatthu, Paṭṭhāna (Abhidhamma Piṭaka); for §5 also the Brahmajāla Sutta (DN 1), the Saṃyutta's chapter on the beginningless round (SN 15), and the Milindapañha (also §7), canonical in this edition onlycompiled over the last centuries BCE; the Kathāvatthu is traditionally dated to the Third Council
commentaryVisuddhimagga, Sammohavinodanī (Vibhaṅga commentary), Atthasālinī (Dhammasaṅgaṇī commentary), the Kathāvatthu, Puggalapaññatti and Paṭṭhāna commentaries; for §5 also the commentaries on the Dīgha, Saṃyutta, Aṅguttara and Suttanipātac. 5th century CE
manualAbhidhammatthasaṅgaha (Anuruddha)variously dated; commonly c. 11th–12th century
sub-commentaryAbhidhammatthavibhāvinī-ṭīkā (Sumaṅgala); also the Mūlaṭīkā on the Vibhaṅga and on the Paṭṭhāna with their Anuṭīkās, the Mūlaṭīkā on the Dhammasaṅgaṇī (§7 only), the Dhammasaṅgaṇī Anuṭīkā, the Dīgha and Aṅguttara sub-commentaries, the Sāratthadīpanī (on the Vinaya), the Visuddhimagga Mahāṭīkā and a sub-commentary on the Abhidhammāvatāra (§4.2 and §4.8 only)c. 12th century for the Vibhāvinī; the Mūlaṭīkā is earlier, since the Vibhāvinī names its author (Mūlaṭīkākārādayo, abh07t.nrf.xml:5553)
grammarPayogasiddhi, a Pāli grammar, used in §5.2 for one unit onlymedieval
modern exegesisLedi Sayadaw, Paramatthadīpanī (on the manual), its Anudīpanī (his own, by its colophon) and Paṭṭhānuddesa-dīpanīc. 1900

A claim that holds only at a later layer is not a claim about the canon. Several rows below live, or die, on exactly that distinction.

In the passages added on 2026-11-14 (findings 9 and 10, §5.4, §9) each statement also carries a short stratum tag: [C] canon, [S] commentary, sub-commentary or later systematization, [X] an import from outside the tradition, here the physics. The tags are read as in this paper, not as in any other scheme that uses the same letters.


1 · What Kind of Comparison This Is

Physics has two great theories that do not fit together. General relativity describes gravity as the smooth geometry of spacetime. Quantum theory describes everything else as discrete, probabilistic excitations. A theory of quantum gravity would describe what spacetime is at the smallest scale, where both matter. Two of the candidate programmes make spacetime itself discrete:

The Theravāda Abhidhamma is also a discrete analysis. It resolves experience and matter into momentary phenomena (dhamma), connected by twenty-four typed conditioning relations. It gives matter a smallest cluster, and it gives space a definition.

It is therefore tempting to line the two up. That temptation has a long and mostly poor history, from The Tao of Physics onward, and this paper is built to resist it. Every row below is a structural comparison: it asks whether two frameworks share a shape (an order, an adjacency, a ratio), and it names exactly where the shape stops being shared. The Abhidhamma is an analysis of what can be known in experience. Quantum gravity is a theory of what spacetime is. Whether the two can be compared at all is the strongest objection to this paper, and §8 carries it rather than answering it.

The map, in one table:

  ROW          PHYSICS SIDE                          ABHIDHAMMA SIDE                        SURVIVING FORM
  ───────────  ────────────────────────────────────  ─────────────────────────────────────  ──────────────────────────────────
  1 ORDER      causal set: a locally finite           the Paṭṭhāna's 24 typed conditions    only the earlier→later MODES (S) are
               partial order ("before")               (classified by manual + sub-comm.)    acyclic, by selection: a strict order,
                                                                                            not yet a causal set; S also orders
                                                                                            across streams (kamma-born colour);
                                                                                            the rest is typing a causal set lacks
  2 GRAIN      spin-network node: a quantum OF        rūpa-kalāpa: smallest material        survives only as what row 3
               space, with a volume                   cluster (matter IN space)             presupposes; matter ≠ geometry;
                                                                                            its one textual size collides
                                                                                            with nuclear structure (§4.8)
  3 BOUNDARY   spin-network link: the face two        paricchedarūpa: the non-mixing of     both put the unit of spatial
               grains share; carries quantised area   touching neighbours; "limit of matter" boundary at the ADJACENCY, not in
                                                                                            a unit (strongest row; the shared
                                                                                            part is generic; seven breaks)
  4 RATIO      proper time ∝ length of the longest    most matter lasts 17 mind-moments     dated on a stream's own moments where
               chain between two events               (51 sub-moments)                      there is one, a UNIT where there is
                                                                                            none; only the generic part survives:
                                                                                            a duration as a count
  ─ DROPPED ─  quantum causal histories               saṅkhāra (the conditioned as a whole)  category error; added no structure

Rows 2 and 3 are one argument told from two ends, so they share one section (§4).


2 · A Note on Discreteness

Two different things are called discrete in this paper, and they must not be confused.

The Abhidhamma has object discreteness in abundance: moments, clusters, sub-moments. Its quantities are restricted only as counts of discrete units: a duration is a whole number of sub-moments, and a size is a step on a ladder of powers of thirty-six (§4.2). It never quantises a magnitude that is not a count, and that is what spectral discreteness is. In particular, its delimiting space (manual and sub-commentary) is assigned no magnitude at all (§4.6). This single fact limits every row below.

Continuity and magnitude are designations, for mind and for matter. The Puggalapaññatti commentary reports a method "outside the commentary, of the teachers" (aṭṭhakathāmuttakena pana ācariyanayena, abh03a.att.xml:741). It places "long, short, far, near" among designations by relation (upanidhāpaññatti, :745), "two, three, four" among designations by placing in series (upanikkhittapaññatti, :753), and "eighty years old", a designation that looks to the absence of a break in continuity (santativicchedābhāvaṃ apekkhitvā), among designations by continuity (santatipaññatti, :753). Of that list only the designation of a dhamma's own nature (earth, heat, hardness) is on the real side; the rest "belong to the unreal side" (avijjamānapakkhañceva, :753). Time and direction are designations depending on the turning of sun and moon (:741), and shape designations are also unreal (:757). Three limits apply. This is the teachers' method as reported, not the canon. It makes the numeral unreal and leaves the plurality of dhammas real. And it does not make all designation unreal: some place-designations and the designation of the unconditioned name what exists (:757).

This settles a status and not a structure. The rows of the formal model that concern mind alone (kala/AXIOMS.md, A1, A3, A7, A24, A104, A112, A117, A126–A128) contain no symbol for matter, so they constrain none; that is true by construction (d3_inner_rows_say_nothing_of_matter). Matter's temporal discreteness enters only through the rows that state it: the seventeen-moment life (A4), the Visuddhimagga's clause on matter's sub-moments in A40, production (A64) and the kalāpas (A66). So the discreteness of the mental stream entails no discrete outer base.

Nor is the texts' continuity a physicist's continuum. A stream in which each moment has an immediate successor cannot be dense, since between a moment and its successor no moment lies (d2_proximity_forbids_density, with a model showing the premises are consistent). The texts' language fits: the compactness of continuity is the going-on of earlier and later "as if become one, through their having no interval" (purimapacchimānaṃ nirantaratāya ekībhūtānamiva pavatti santatighanatā, abh01t.tik.xml:681). This holds for the mental stream only. The Vibhaṅga Anuṭīkā denies that relation to matter (na hi rūpadhammānaṃ arūpadhammānaṃ viya anantarapaccayabhāvo atthi, abh02t.tik.xml:4921), and describes matter's series as linked like a chain (saṅkhalikassa viya sambandho, :4921), which a dense family could also satisfy.


3 · Row 1 — Order

3.1 · Physics primer: partial orders and causal sets

A relation is a rule that says, for any two things x and y, whether x stands in it to y. "Is an ancestor of" is a relation on people. Write it x ≺ y.

A partial order is a relation with two properties:

  irreflexive:   never  x ≺ x                       (nothing precedes itself)
  transitive:    if  x ≺ y  and  y ≺ z,  then  x ≺ z  (ancestors of ancestors are ancestors)

Together these make it acyclic: you can never follow the arrows and return to where you started. It is called partial because some pairs are not related either way. Two cousins are neither ancestor of the other.

A causal set is a partial order on a set of events, with one more property, local finiteness: between any two related events, only finitely many events lie. The relation means "can causally influence". In relativity, two events are either causally related (one is in the other's past light cone) or spacelike: too far apart in space, for the time between them, for any signal to connect them. In a causal set, spacelike simply means unrelated.

Links and the Hasse diagram. If x ≺ y and nothing lies between them, the pair is a link (mathematicians say covering relation). Drawing only the links, with later events higher, gives the Hasse diagram. Every other relation can be recovered by following links upward, since the order is transitive.

            e       f            later events higher
             \     /
              \   /
                d                only LINKS are drawn;
              /   \              a ≺ d, a ≺ e, a ≺ f, b ≺ e … follow by transitivity
             b     c
              \   /              b and c are UNRELATED (spacelike):
                a                neither can influence the other

Order plus number. Sorkin's slogan for the programme is order + number = geometry. Two classical theorems (Hawking, King and McCarthy 1976; Malament 1977) show that, for spacetimes that are past- and future-distinguishing, the causal order fixes the geometry up to a conformal factor, that is, up to a local scale. Causal set theory supplies the missing scale by counting. Events are scattered at random (a "sprinkling") with, on average, one event per unit of spacetime volume in Planck units, so the number of events in a region measures its volume.

Time as chain length. A chain is a sequence x₁ ≺ x₂ ≺ … ≺ xₙ. Between two related events, the length of the longest chain grows in proportion to the proper time between them: the time a clock carried from one to the other would read. The result holds asymptotically and in expectation, for random sprinklings into Minkowski space (Brightwell and Gregory 1991). In a causal set, a duration is a count of steps. §5 uses exactly this.

Growth. In Rideout and Sorkin's sequential-growth models, the causal set is not given all at once. It grows, one element at a time, each new element born to the future of some existing ones. What is born stays. Sorkin reads this as a real becoming, a growing block: a past that accumulates and a future that does not yet exist.

3.2 · The Abhidhamma side: twenty-four typed relations

The Paṭṭhāna, the last book of the Abhidhamma Piṭaka (canon), analyses how phenomena condition one another under twenty-four named conditions (paccaya). The manual (Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha, ch. 8) summarises them, and the sub-commentary (the Vibhāvinī) classifies each by the time its conditioning reaches. On the manual's ch. 8 it states:

… anantarasamanantaraāsevananatthivigatavasena pañcannaṃ atītakālikānaṃ, kammapaccayassa atītavattamānavasena dvikālikassa, ārammaṇaadhipatiupanissayapaccayānaṃ tikālikānaṃ, itaresaṃ pannarasannaṃ paccuppannakālikānañca vasena kālattayavanto, nibbānapaññattivasena kālavimuttā ca …

… [things are] possessed of the three times by way of the five belonging to the past (proximity, contiguity, repetition, absence, disappearance), the kamma condition belonging to two times (past and present), the object, predominance and decisive-support conditions belonging to three times, and the remaining fifteen belonging to the present; and free of time, by way of nibbāna and concepts …

The count checks: 5 + 1 + 3 + 15 = 24. The tetrad sorts the conditions by the time their conditioning state may have, and the same sentence then sets the time-free (nibbāna and concepts) beside the three times. So the classification is not exhaustive of what can condition: the object condition, placed among the three-time conditions, also reaches the time-free.

The remaining fifteen are root (hetu), co-nascence, mutuality, support (nissaya), pre-nascence, post-nascence, result (vipāka), nutriment (āhāra), faculty (indriya), jhāna, path (magga), association (sampayutta), dissociation (vippayutta), presence (atthi) and non-disappearance (avigata). "Belonging to the present" means the conditioning state exists when the conditioned one does. It does not mean that the two arose together. Pre-nascence belongs to the present because its condition arose earlier and still stands. So "present" is not "co-nascent", and several of the fifteen have modes, which the canon itself names. The Paṭṭhāna gives the presence condition as sahajātaṃ, purejātaṃ, pacchājātaṃ, āhāraṃ, indriyaṃ (co-nascent, pre-nascent, post-nascent, nutriment, faculty), and the dissociation condition as sahajātaṃ, purejātaṃ, pacchājātaṃ. The manual groups the modes (ch. 8, CST §30–§34):

ConditionCo-nascent modePre-nascent mode (condition arose earlier)Post-nascent mode
support (nissaya)mind with mind, the great elements with derived matterthe six bases for the seven consciousness elements, during the course of existence—
faculty (indriya)the immaterial faculties for co-nascent mind and matterthe five sensitivities for the five kinds of sense consciousness— (the material life faculty, for the matter of its own cluster, is a third, separate mode)
dissociation (vippayutta)mind for co-nascent matter; the base at rebirth-linkingthe six bases, during the course of existence, purejātavasenalater mind for the earlier-arisen body
presence, non-disappearance (atthi, avigata)sahajātaṃpurejātaṃpacchājātaṃ (edible food and material life are two further, separate modes)

The manual names the pre-nascent mode in words for dissociation, presence and non-disappearance. For support and faculty the pre-nascent reading is the one the canon gives for the base (vatthu kusalānaṃ khandhānaṃ nissayapaccayena paccayo) and the one the standard modern exposition gives for the sensitivities (Bodhi 1993, ch. VIII: "prenascence faculty"). At rebirth-linking the base arises together with the mind and is co-nascent, which is why the manual limits the pre-nascent mode to the course of existence.

A condition in the Abhidhamma is typed. The relation is not just "x conditions y", but "x conditions y as object", "as kamma", "as co-nascent", and so on. One pair can stand in several types at once.

3.3 · The correspondence, and its surviving form

The whole is not a partial order. Four features break it:

FeatureText (layer)Why it is not a partial order
Mutuality (aññamañña)canon; manual ch. 8x conditions y and y conditions x: a 2-cycle. A partial order forbids cycles.
Co-nascence (sahajāta)canon; manual ch. 8relates what arises together. A causal order leaves simultaneous, unlinked events unrelated (spacelike).
Post-nascence (pacchājāta)manual ch. 8: "pacchājātā cittacetasikā dhammā purejātassa imassa kāyassa pacchājātavasena" — "later-arisen consciousness and its concomitants [condition] this body, arisen earlier, by way of post-nascence"the condition arises after what it supports: ordered by arising, the arrow runs backward.
Object (ārammaṇa)manual ch. 3: mind-door objects may be "paccuppannamatītaṃ anāgataṃ kālavimuttañca" (present, past, future, and free of time); the sub-commentary glosses the time-free as "nibbānaṃ, paññatti ca" (nibbāna and concepts)a future object conditions a present mind, and a time-free object is in no order at all.

The surviving form. Because several conditions have modes, the surviving relation is defined over condition-modes, not over whole conditions. Some modes always run from what arose earlier to what arises later:

  the ACYCLIC SUB-RELATION S  (defined over MODES)
  ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
  anantara, samanantara     the moment just ceased → the next moment
  āsevana                   a moment → the next, as repetition
  natthi, vigata            the moment just ceased → the next (by its absence)
  purejāta                  an earlier-arisen, still-present base or object → a later-arising mind
  kamma (nānākkhaṇika)      a past volition → its later result, across many moments
  pre-nascent MODES of      the same earlier-arisen bases (and, for faculty, the five
    nissaya, indriya,         sensitivities) → the later-arising consciousness, during the
    vippayutta, atthi,        course of existence
    avigata

The co-nascent and post-nascent modes of those five conditions stay out of S, and so does kamma's co-nascent mode.

Every one of the twenty-four, assigned:

Where it goesConditions (or modes)
in S (whole condition)proximity, contiguity, repetition, absence, disappearance, pre-nascence
in S (one mode only)kamma (across moments); support, faculty, dissociation, presence, non-disappearance (pre-nascent modes)
out: co-nascent onlyroot, co-nascence, mutuality, result, jhāna, path, association; the co-nascent modes of kamma, support, faculty, dissociation, presence, non-disappearance, predominance and nutriment
out: runs backwardpost-nascence; the post-nascent modes of dissociation, presence and non-disappearance
out: reaches three times, or the time-freeobject, predominance (object mode), decisive support
out: not sorted by arising herenutriment (edible food); faculty and presence (material life), whose relata co-exist in one body without a stated arising order

Why S is acyclic (a one-line proof). Let t(x) be the moment at which phenomenon x arises. For every mode in S, x S y implies t(x) < t(y). Along any chain x₁ S x₂ S … S xₙ, the arising times strictly increase, so the chain can never return to x₁. This proof shows less than it seems to. S was selected by the condition t(x) < t(y), so its acyclicity follows from the selection and is not a finding about the text. A strict order can be read over S, and its transitive closure is a partial order. But the closure is the reader's construction (see the next paragraph), and whether S meets the rest of §3.1's definition is taken up in §3.4.

One condition was removed from S by the adversarial review. The original list included pakatūpanissaya (natural decisive support). The sub-commentary classes decisive support as tikālika, reaching all three times (quoted above), and the manual's list of natural decisive supports includes present things (a person, climate, food, lodging). It is therefore not guaranteed to run earlier-to-later, and it is out.

A second, smaller correspondence: generators, not closure. The manual and the sub-commentary present the conditions as primitive. Neither says that because x conditions y and y conditions z, x conditions z. Whether the Paṭṭhāna itself anywhere composes two conditions into a third is part of the canonical check this paper owes (§11); U Nārada's translation (1969), which works through the Paṭṭhāna's own permutations, is the route for it. On the manual's presentation, the relations are primitive, like a causal set presented by its links rather than by its full transitive order. The likeness is partial. Proximity (anantara) holds only between immediate successors, so it is link-like in the strict Hasse sense. Kamma across moments, however, spans many intermediate moments and is still primitive, so S is a set of generating relations that is neither the Hasse diagram nor the full order.

The surviving form of the row, stated once:

As the manual and the Vibhāvinī classify the Paṭṭhāna's conditions, the condition-modes that always run from earlier-arising to later-arising (proximity, contiguity, repetition, absence, disappearance, pre-nascence, kamma across moments, and the pre-nascent modes of support, faculty, dissociation, presence and non-disappearance) form an acyclic typed relation over which a strict order, but not yet a causal set in §3.1's sense, can be read. The remaining conditions and modes (the co-nascent ones, the post-nascent ones, and the object, predominance and decisive-support conditions that reach all three times) are typed structure that a causal set does not have.

3.4 · Where it breaks

Order between streams. The sibling paper Twenty-Four Kinds of Because (§4.7) finds that no condition joins two mental continua and that two people have no shared clock. No shared clock is not no order, and S itself carries some. Kamma across moments runs from a past volition to its results, and the canon counts matter among them (nānākkhaṇikā – kusalā cetanā vipākānaṃ khandhānaṃ kaṭattā ca rūpānaṃ kammapaccayena paccayo, Paṭṭhāna, abh03m7.mul.xml:6065; manual ch. 8 §17, abh07t.nrf.xml:2865). Kamma-produced matter includes visible form (rūpaṃ kammassa katattā rūpāyatanaṃ, Dhammasaṅgaṇī §652, abh01m.mul.xml:5549), and every kamma-born cluster carries the inseparable eight, colour (vaṇṇa) among them (manual ch. 6 §46, §27, abh07t.nrf.xml:2273, :2169). Colour is a pre-nascent object for the five-door process of whoever sees it (pañcārammaṇāni ca pañcaviññāṇavīthiyā purejātavasena, manual ch. 8 §19, abh07t.nrf.xml:2873). Both edges are in S. A second route runs through mind-born matter: a mind originates matter by co-nascence (cittacetasikā dhammā aññamaññaṃ sahajātarūpānañca, ch. 8 §28, abh07t.nrf.xml:2909), at its own arising sub-moment (Sammohavinodanī, abh02a.att.xml:409), and mind-born octads carry colour too (ch. 6 §47, abh07t.nrf.xml:2277).

  stream A   … a₀ ·········· a₁ ──── a₂ ──── a₃ …        proximity (in S)
               │ kamma, across          │ co-nascent: arises WITH a₂
               ▼ moments (in S)         ▼ (NOT in S)
  matter     kamma-born colour        mind-born colour     each lasts 17 mind-moments
               │                        │
               │ pre-nascent object: arose EARLIER, still present (in S)
               ▼                        ▼
  stream B   … b₁ ──────────────────── b₂ …                 eye-consciousnesses that see them

  t(a₀) < t(colour) < t(b₁):  an order ACROSS streams, carried by S alone
  t(a₂) = t(colour) < t(b₂):  the same kind of order, through one edge S excludes

The carrier is the colour, never the bodily intimation, which lasts one mind-moment (§5.2) and is not visible. Three limits apply. (1) Each route is the reader's composition of two edges the texts state separately. (2) The mind-born route lives only in the larger relation of S with the co-nascent modes, whose reflexive-transitive closure is a preorder, not a partial order: mutuality relates co-nascent phenomena both ways (ch. 8 §29, including the base and the resultant mind at rebirth-linking, paṭisandhikkhaṇe vatthuvipākā aññamaññaṃ, abh07t.nrf.xml:2913). But its cycles all lie inside co-nascent clusters (a mind with its factors, the great elements of one cluster, the base with the resultant mind), none of which spans two streams, and every S edge raises the arising time, so the order it gives between streams is strict. "Preorder" describes the whole relation, not its cross-stream part. (3) Neither route makes S a causal set. As a lens only, this is relativity's shape rather than a causal set's: no global clock, yet a causal order between separate places, carried here by matter as there by signals. Nothing here bounds a speed, and the co-nascent cycles have no light-cone counterpart.

Co-nascence also presupposes a simultaneity, of a mind and the matter it originates, that a causal set lacks; a claim that one mind-moment occurs everywhere at once was checked and found no textual basis. For §3.5's third falsifier the result is mixed. S connects the kamma route, but the mind-born pair (a₂ before b₂) is an order the texts' own definitions imply and S alone cannot connect, so the falsifier is engaged in a narrowed form: S carries part of the order between streams, not all of it.

3.5 · What would falsify this row


4 · Rows 2 and 3 — Grain and Boundary: Where Space Is

4.1 · Physics primer: spin networks, and what "area has a discrete spectrum" means

Geometry is a field. In general relativity, the gravitational field is the geometry of spacetime: it decides lengths, areas and volumes. There is no stage apart from it. If the gravitational field is quantised, then lengths, areas and volumes become quantum quantities, and quantum quantities typically come in steps.

What "spectrum" means. In quantum theory, each measurable quantity is represented by an operator: a rule which, given the state of a system, yields the possible results of measuring it. The list of possible results is the quantity's spectrum. A spectrum is discrete if the possible results are separated by gaps. Think of a function that can only take values on the rungs of a ladder. An electron's energy in an atom has a discrete spectrum, and that is why atoms emit light at sharp colours. Loop quantum gravity finds that area and volume have discrete spectra (Rovelli and Smolin 1995; Ashtekar and Lewandowski 1997).

A spin network. A quantum state of space in loop quantum gravity is described by a graph: points (nodes) joined by lines (links). Each link carries a label j called a spin, taking values j = ½, 1, 3/2, 2, …. Each node carries a second label, the intertwiner, which records how the links meeting there fit together.

                 j₁
                 │
         j₄ ─────●───── j₂          ● a NODE: a grain ("quantum") of space
                 │n                  each line: a LINK, labelled by a spin j
                 j₃                  the node's volume depends on j₁…j₄ and the intertwiner

Area lives on links. Take any surface. Its area is a sum over the links that pierce it:

  A  =  8πγ ℓ_P²  Σ  √( j (j + 1) )          sum over the links crossing the surface

  ℓ_P  = √(ħG / c³)  ≈  1.6 × 10⁻³⁵ m       the Planck length
  γ    = the Barbero–Immirzi parameter, a dimensionless constant of the theory
         (γ ≈ 0.2375 from black-hole entropy counting, Domagala–Lewandowski
          and Meissner 2004; ≈ 0.274 under the later Ghosh–Mitra counting;
          the value depends on the state-counting convention)

This is the formula for links that cross the surface transversally. When a node lies on the surface itself, the general formula adds further terms (Ashtekar and Lewandowski 1997). The smallest non-zero area is one link with j = ½:

  A_min  =  8πγ ℓ_P² √(3/4)  =  4√3 π γ ℓ_P²   ≈  21.8 γ ℓ_P²

There is nothing between zero and this value. That gap is what "area has a discrete spectrum" means.

Volume lives at nodes. Each node has a volume, but volume is not an independent label. It is computed from the spins of the links meeting there and from the intertwiner, and it takes discrete values. A node where only three links meet has zero volume: the volume operator vanishes on gauge-invariant two- and three-valent nodes (Loll 1995 for the three-valent case, restated in Loll 1996, which computed the four-valent spectrum). In the geometric picture below, the same fact reads simply: three faces whose area-vectors sum to zero must lie in one plane, and a flat shape has no volume. Volume needs at least four links.

Nodes are quanta of space, not things in space. Rovelli (Zakopane lectures, §I.A): the quanta of gravity "do not live in space, but give rise to space themselves." There is no background in which the network sits. "Where" means "which node, adjacent to which".

Grains and faces. Bianchi, Doná and Speziale (2011) showed that a node can be read as a small polyhedron, a quantum polyhedron, whose faces are its links. The reading is semiclassical: coherent spin-network states represent semiclassical polyhedra, which is most reliable at large spins and least trustworthy at small spins, including the j = ½ where the smallest area sits. Adjacency is also definite only for a spin-network basis state on a fixed graph; a general quantum state of space is a superposition of graphs. Rovelli states the consequence plainly (Zakopane lectures, §II.F): "Two grains n and n′ are adjacent if there is a link l connecting the two, and in this case the area of the elementary surface separating the two grains is determined by the spin of the link joining n and n′."

   ┌───────────────┐┌───────────────┐
   │   grain  n    ││   grain  n′   │       the face they share IS the link l;
   │   (volume)    ││   (volume)    │       its area = 8πγℓ_P² √(j_l (j_l + 1))
   └───────────────┘└───────────────┘

   the same thing as a graph:     n ●────────── j_l ──────────● n′

In one sentence: in loop quantum gravity, the boundary between two neighbouring grains of space is the adjacency itself, and it carries a quantised area.

4.2 · The Abhidhamma side: the grain

The kalāpa is matter. The smallest material cluster (rūpa-kalāpa) is not in the canonical Abhidhamma books. The Dhammasaṅgaṇī has no kalāpa vocabulary. The clusters appear in the commentary (the Visuddhimagga names the "pure octad", suddhaṭṭhaka, and the decads), and the manual systematises them into twenty-one kinds (Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha ch. 6: "kalāpā ekavīsati"). The simplest, the pure octad, is eight inseparable material phenomena: the four great elements (extension, cohesion, heat, motion) together with colour, odour, taste and nutritive essence.

The commentarial size ladder. The Vibhaṅga commentary (Sammohavinodanī), in a passage teaching a monk to see small faults as large, gives a ladder of sizes:

chattiṃsa paramāṇavo ekassa aṇuno pamāṇaṃ. Chattiṃsa aṇū ekāya tajjāriyā pamāṇaṃ. Chattiṃsa tajjāriyo eko rathareṇu.

Thirty-six paramāṇu make the measure of one aṇu; thirty-six aṇu, one tajjārī; thirty-six tajjārī, one rathareṇu [a mote of chariot dust].

So one paramāṇu is 1/36³ = 1/46,656 of a chariot-dust mote. The commentary describes the paramāṇu as ākāsakoṭṭhāsika, of the order of a portion of space, and says it is visible only to the divine eye. The ladder is for the paramāṇu, not the kalāpa. The commentary does not use the word kalāpa there.

The identification of the two is a sub-commentary's, and it is contested. An earlier version of this section called it "later exegesis, common in modern summaries". That was wrong. Modern summaries repeat the identification, but they did not originate it. The Visuddhimagga Mahāṭīkā makes the identification, as the reason the powder mode of the four-elements meditation is taught:

Te pana kalāpā paramāṇuparimāṇā hontīti tappariyāpannānaṃ pathavīdhātuādīnaṃ ekasmiṃ sarīre parimeyyaparicchedaṃ dassetuṃ cuṇṇato manasikātabbatā vuttā.

Because those kalāpas are of paramāṇu size, attention by way of powder is taught, in order to show the measurable delimitation, in one body, of the earth element and the rest contained in them. (e0103n.att.xml:6229)

The same work reports a different ladder, of successive eighths, as the view of "some" (keci), and sets it aside for the commentary's (e0103n.att.xml:6257). Ledi Sayadaw declines the identification by name:

Yaṃ pana mahāṭīkāyaṃ te pana kalāpā paramāṇuparimāṇā hontīti vuttaṃ. Taṃ dhātūnaṃ cuṇṇamanasikārānurūpamattavasena vuttanti gahetabbaṃ.

What is said in the Mahāṭīkā, "those kalāpas are of paramāṇu size", is to be taken as said merely in conformity with the powder-attention to the elements. (Paramatthadīpanī, e0301n.nrf.xml:4705)

His own reason bounds the kalāpa from above: the embryo at rebirth-linking, three kalāpas' measure, "would be smaller even than a paramāṇu", because a paramāṇu, occurring by continuity as a mass of kalāpas accumulated moment by moment, would be "at the lower limit, of the measure of forty-nine kalāpas" (heṭṭhima koṭiyā ekūnapaññāsakalāpaparimāṇoeva siyā, :4705). So one kalāpa is at most a forty-ninth of a paramāṇu, with no lower size given. His Anudīpanī, which its colophon makes his own work (e0401n.nrf.xml:1725–:1729), compresses this to "a paramāṇu is of the measure of forty-nine kalāpas", and adds a harmonizing reading on which the Mahāṭīkā's line "is also fitting as said taking the accumulated measure of the embryo" (kalalassa vā upacitappamāṇaṃ gahetvā vuttantipi yujjati, e0401n.nrf.xml:1261).

The tradition's own bridge from time to count to size. A sub-commentary on the Abhidhammāvatāra says of the eye-sensitivity that its own measure is "very subtle, with the paramāṇu as its limit" (paramāṇupariyantena pamāṇena atisukhumameva), and that it occurs in forty-nine kalāpas together, "because material phenomena have a life of seventeen mind-moments, and because kamma-born matter arises at each of the three sub-moments of every mind" (abh08t.nrf.xml:7373). Seventeen times three is fifty-one. The step from fifty-one to forty-nine (fifty-one groups present at any sub-moment, forty-nine of them at their presence phase) is this paper's arithmetic, checked in d6_present_window, d6_standing_window and d6_counts_at_100. It agrees with the Vibhāvinī's forty-nine for decay (abh07t.nrf.xml:4837), and the Vibhaṅga Anuṭīkā reaches forty-nine by adding the dissolution-born to a series of forty-eight (abh02t.tik.xml:4921). The count follows from time, and the size does not. §4.8 takes up what happens if the size is read as a length.

4.3 · The Abhidhamma side: the boundary, in four layers

Canon — a cavity. The Dhammasaṅgaṇī (§637) defines the space element:

Katamaṃ taṃ rūpaṃ ākāsadhātu? Yo ākāso ākāsagataṃ aghaṃ aghagataṃ vivaro vivaragataṃ asamphuṭṭhaṃ catūhi mahābhūtehi — idaṃ taṃ rūpaṃ ākāsadhātu.

What is the material phenomenon that is the space element? That which is space, belonging to space, void, belonging to the void, an opening, belonging to an opening, untouched by the four great elements — this is the space element.

The Vibhaṅga, also canon, gives examples of the internal space element: the ear-holes, the nostrils, the mouth, the passage by which food is swallowed, where it rests and where it leaves. At the canonical layer, space is a cavity with extent: a gap in matter, the kind of thing that has room in it.

Canon — not unconditioned. The Kathāvatthu (VI.6, §460–462, verified in the Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana text) refutes the thesis "ākāso asaṅkhato", that space is unconditioned. One of its arguments is homely: "Udapāne khaññamāne anākāso ākāso hotīti? Āmantā." When a well is dug, does what was not space become space? Yes. And when an empty jar is filled, space disappears. Something that can be made and unmade is not unconditioned. The commentary attributes the rejected thesis to the Uttarāpathakas and the Mahisāsakas (so spelled there). The Mahiṃsāsakas are one of the four Vibhajjavādin branches in Cousins's account (Cousins 2001), which the sibling paper uses. Once again, the branch that kept the Pāli canon argues against a sibling branch.

Commentary — three spaces, and a characterisation. The Kathāvatthu commentary distinguishes three spaces:

tividho ākāso — paricchedākāso, kasiṇugghāṭimākāso, ajaṭākāso … Tesu paricchedākāso saṅkhato, itare dve paññattimattā.

Space is threefold: delimiting space, the space left by removing a meditation disk, and unentangled [open] space … Of these, delimiting space is conditioned; the other two are mere concepts.

The commentary's classing of open space as a concept is disputed within the tradition: the Atthasālinī reads the Dhammasaṅgaṇī's space element as unentangled space (§7).

The Visuddhimagga (ch. XIV, CST ¶442) characterises the space element in its fourfold formula:

Rūpaparicchedalakkhaṇā ākāsadhātu, rūpapariyantappakāsanarasā, rūpamariyādapaccupaṭṭhānā, asamphuṭṭhabhāvacchiddavivarabhāvapaccupaṭṭhānā vā, paricchinnarūpapadaṭṭhānā. Yāya paricchinnesu rūpesu idamito uddhamadho tiriyanti ca hoti.

The space element has the characteristic of delimiting matter; its function is to display the boundaries of matter; it is manifested as the confines of matter, or as the state of being untouched, as holes and openings; its proximate cause is the matter delimited. It is that by which one can say of delimited material things, "this is above, below, around that."

The last sentence matters for §4.5. Direction and position are defined only relative to delimited matter.

Manual — not a constituent. The Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha (ch. 6, the verse closing the section on kalāpas):

Kalāpānaṃ pariccheda-lakkhaṇattā vicakkhaṇā; Na kalāpaṅgamiccāhu, ākāsaṃ lakkhaṇāni ca.

Because space has the characteristic of delimiting the kalāpas, and because of the nature of the characteristics, the wise do not call space, nor the characteristics, a constituent of a kalāpa.

Space is between kalāpas, never in one. The manual also classes this delimiting matter (paricchedarūpa) as anipphanna: not concretely produced, with no intrinsic nature of its own. The term is older than the manual; the Visuddhimagga and the Sammohavinodanī already use it. It is counted as one of the twenty-eight material phenomena, but the standard expositions do not count it among the ultimate realities (Bodhi 1993, ch. VI), and one reads it as "nothing but the mere limitation of matter" (Karunadasa 1967, ch. 5).

Sub-commentary — the non-mixing of touching neighbours. The Vibhāvinī, on the same chapter:

Cakkhudasakādiekekakalāpagatarūpānaṃ kalāpantarehi asaṃkiṇṇabhāvāpādanavasena paricchedakaṃ, tehi vā paricchijjamānaṃ, tesaṃ paricchedamattaṃ vā rūpaṃ paricchedarūpaṃ … Vijjamānepi ca kalāpantarabhūtehi kalāpantarabhūtānaṃ samphuṭṭhabhāve taṃtaṃrūpavivittatā rūpapariyanto ākāso. Yesañca so paricchedo, tehi sayaṃ asamphuṭṭhoyeva. Aññathā paricchinnatā na siyā tesaṃ rūpānaṃ byāpībhāvāpattito. Abyāpitā hi asamphuṭṭhatā.

Delimiting matter is what delimits the matter in each kalāpa (the eye-decad and the rest) by making it unmixed with neighbouring kalāpas; or what is delimited by them; or their mere delimitation … Even where neighbouring kalāpas touch one another, space is the separateness of each one's matter, the limit of matter. And it is itself untouched by the things it delimits. Otherwise those material things would not be delimited, since they would come to pervade one another. For non-pervasion is non-touching.

   ┌────────────┐ ┊ ┌────────────┐
   │ kalāpa K₁  │ ┊ │ kalāpa K₂  │      K₁ and K₂ may TOUCH;
   │ (8+ rūpas) │ ┊ │ (8+ rūpas) │      space is the ┊ : their non-mixing,
   └────────────┘ ┊ └────────────┘      "the limit of matter"
                  ↑
         paricchedarūpa — not a constituent of either (manual);
         untouched by what it bounds (sub-commentary);
         no nature of its own; no magnitude assigned (anipphanna);
         its proximate cause is the matter it delimits (commentary)

4.4 · An older neighbour: do minimal units touch? (cross-tradition: Sarvāstivāda, in Sanskrit)

The Vibhāvinī's wording answers a question the Indian schools had argued for centuries. The Abhidharmakośabhāṣya (ad I.43, Pradhan ed., pp. 32–33) asks it directly:

kiṃ punaḥ paramāṇavaḥ spṛśanty anyonyam āhosvin na / na spṛśantīti kāśmīrakāḥ / … yadi tāvat sarvātmanā spṛśeyur miśrībhaveyur dravyāṇi / athaikadeśena sāvayavāḥ prasajyeran / niravayavāś ca paramāṇavaḥ

Do atoms touch one another, or not? The Kashmiri masters say they do not touch. … If they touched with their whole selves, the substances would mix. If they touched with a part, they would have parts. But atoms are partless.

The same passage adds that contact means only arising without interval, and that "their being without interval is just that there is nothing between them" (tad evaiṣāṃ nirantaratvaṃ yan madhye nāsti kiñcit). The form nirantaratvaṃ is this paper's emendation: the GRETIL e-text reads niruttaratvaṃ [032|20]. The emendation follows the passage's own nirantara in the line before, and Pradhan's printed page was not checked. Bhadanta Vasumitra holds that they do not touch, and that we call it touching when there is no interval.

Two cautions before the comparison. First, the Kośa's contact debate concerns partless atoms (paramāṇu). Its functional counterpart of the kalāpa is a different item, the smallest aggregate of eight substances (aṣṭadravyaka, ad II.22), the counterpart of the pure octad. So the comparison below is of the role of minimal units, and it does not identify the Kośa's atom with the Sammohavinodanī's paramāṇu (which §4.2 already keeps apart from the kalāpa). Second, the Kośa also has a conditioned space element. Besides unconditioned ākāśa (I.5), it names the cavity: dvāravātāyanamukhanāsikādiṣu chidram ākāśadhātvākhyam (I.28, [018|13]), "the hole in a door, a window, the mouth, the nose and so on is called the space element", which it says is light and darkness (ālokatamasī kila). That is a close parallel to the Vibhaṅga's ear-holes and nostrils (§4.3).

The two traditions share the premise: if minimal units truly touched, they would mix. The Vibhāvinī keeps the premise by making touching conventional only: "non-pervasion is non-touching" (abyāpitā hi asamphuṭṭhatā). They draw different conclusions:

Do the units touch?What is between them?
Kashmiri Sarvāstivāda (Kośa ad I.43)nonothing ("nothing between them")
Theravāda sub-commentary (Vibhāvinī)conventionally yes; strictly no (non-pervasion is non-touching)something: delimiting matter, the non-mixing — counted among the material phenomena, though anipphanna and not an ultimate reality
Loop quantum gravitygrains share a facesomething: the link, which carries area

On this one question, the Theravāda answer and loop quantum gravity have the same shape: the between is not nothing. It is a named, counted item of the list (one of the twenty-eight material phenomena in one, a link in the other), and it is not itself one of the minimal units: not a kalāpa, not a node. The Kashmiri answer makes the between empty. Two limits on that shape. The Theravāda item is counted but is not an ultimate reality, and Karunadasa (1967) reads it as the mere limitation of matter, which moves it toward the Kashmiri nothing: what separates the two answers on that reading is that one names and counts the between and the other does not. And the two "neither" relations are opposite in incidence (§4.6, break 6). The Sarvāstivāda counts ākāśa among the unconditioned (I.5), which is the thesis the Kathāvatthu refutes, and separately names the conditioned cavity (I.28).

4.5 · The correspondence, and its surviving form

Both frameworks put the unit of spatial boundary at the adjacency between minimal units. In loop quantum gravity, a spin-network link is the face that two neighbouring grains of space share. In the Vibhāvinī, space is the non-mixing of touching neighbouring kalāpas, "the limit of matter", untouched by what it bounds and a constituent of neither. In neither framework is the boundary itself one of the minimal units. In both, "where" is defined by adjacency and not by a background: Rovelli's quanta "do not live in space", and the Visuddhimagga's space is "that by which one can say of delimited material things, 'this is above, below, around that'".

That is the whole of the claim. The next paragraphs give the tradition's reason for it; everything else in this section limits it.

Why the between is matter's, and never mind's. The tradition gives the reason, from the commentary on. The Paṭṭhāna commentary calls successive mind-moments contiguous "thoroughly without interval, because of the absence of shape" (saṇṭhānābhāvato suṭṭhu anantarāti samanantarā, abh03a.att.xml:7697). Its Mūlaṭīkā spells this out: mental phenomena, lacking shape as material phenomena have it, and with condition and conditioned never standing together, admit no division "this is below, above, across from that" (rūpadhammānaṃ viya saṇṭhānābhāvato paccayapaccayuppannānaṃ sahāvaṭṭhānābhāvato ca "idamito heṭṭhā uddhaṃ tiriya"nti vibhāgābhāvā, abh03t.tik.xml:4305), which is the Visuddhimagga's formula for what space does for matter (§4.3). Its Anuṭīkā ties the absence of division to shapelessness (abh05t.nrf.xml:4637), and the Vibhāvinī defines contiguity by it (saṇṭhānābhāvena suṭṭhu anantarapaccayo samanantarapaccayo, abh07t.nrf.xml:6653). Ledi Sayadaw draws the contrast in so many words: between two material clusters, even bound together in a stone pillar, "there is an interval, an opening; not so between the earlier and later two groups of mind and mental factors", which, having no shape, have no delimiter and no interval at all (dvinnaṃ rūpakalāpānaṃ majjhe antaraṃ nāma vivaraṃ nāma atthiyeva. Na tathā purimapacchimānaṃ dvinnaṃ cittacetasika kalāpānaṃ majjhe, Paṭṭhānuddesa-dīpanī, e0501n.nrf.xml:229).

The two reasons reach differently. Within one stream both hold: no two moments are present at once ("even for Buddhas, two minds do not occur together", buddhānampi hi dve cittāni ekato nappavattanti, Suttanipāta commentary, s0505a.att.xml:685), and what is present together in one moment, consciousness with its factors, is conjoined, "one in arising and ceasing, one in object and base" (ekuppādanirodhā ca, ekālambaṇavatthukā, manual ch. 2 §1, abh07t.nrf.xml:329), the opposite of the non-mixing that defines the delimiter. Across streams, where moments of two minds can be present at once, the second reason does not apply and shapelessness must do the work; these passages speak of succession within a stream and do not discuss that case.

Only the within-stream precondition has been checked by machine, in Lean 4, in the public repository SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma (CC0; software concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23067241), file kala/Time.lean with the definitions in kala/Axioms.lean (commit deb9dec):

  a stream s:   moments, a successor map, and a clock  tick : Moment → ℤ
                one_at_a_time :  tick a = tick b  →  a = b                (A1: tick is injective)
  a kalāpa k:   birth : ℤ ;   k present at t  :=  birth ≤ t < birth + 17
  between k₁ k₂ t  :=  k₁ present at t  ∧  k₂ present at t               (co-presence only)

  theorem mind_has_no_between (s) (t) :   ¬ ∃ a b,  a ≠ b ∧ tick a = t ∧ tick b = t
  theorem matter_can_have_a_between :     ∃ k₁ k₂,  k₁ ≠ k₂ ∧ between k₁ k₂ 5    (a witness)

What the check reaches is small. mind_has_no_between is the one-at-a-time axiom restated as the injectivity of tick; it never mentions between, which is defined only on kalāpas and only as co-presence. Kalāpas carry a birth on an integer line in mind-moment units and are attached to no stream. Nothing in the model touches, adjoins or has a shape, so neither the row's adjacency nor the shapelessness reason is formalised. The run script, re-run for this revision, checks these two and five more theorems in the file, and each of six deliberate breaks of the axioms (among them dropping the one-at-a-time axiom) makes the build fail. The file is exploratory, outside the repository's pre-registration, and its model is the authors'. The asymmetry is also a known shape: a stream is a chain (§3.1), and kalāpas present together play the part of an antichain, a set of elements none of which precedes another; that the between belongs to the antichain adds nothing specific to loop quantum gravity (§9).

The grain row survives only through the boundary row. Kalāpa against node, taken alone, is a comparison of a smallest-unit-of-matter with a smallest-unit-of-space. That is the general "smallest unit" comparison the census found common, and it fails on the matter/geometry distinction below. It earns a line in the table only because the boundary row presupposes minimal units with neighbours.

4.6 · Where it breaks

  1. The dependence runs in opposite directions. In loop quantum gravity, the adjacency data come first: the spins on the links, with the intertwiners, determine the volumes of the nodes. In the Abhidhamma, the matter comes first: the space element's proximate cause is the matter delimited (paricchinnarūpapadaṭṭhānā, commentary). One builds the grain from its boundaries. The other derives the boundary from its grains.
  2. Magnitude. Loop-gravity area is observable and has a discrete spectrum, with a smallest non-zero value. Abhidhamma delimiting matter is anipphanna: it has no nature of its own, and no magnitude is assigned to it. ("No magnitude" is this paper's reading of anipphanna; no text says "it has no size" in those words.) There is no "how much" boundary between two kalāpas. The canonical cavity (break 4) does have extent, but no text measures it. The Abhidhamma boundary is object-discrete (it is one item between two items), but not spectrally discrete (§2).
  3. Matter against geometry. Kalāpas are matter in space. Their octad includes colour, odour and taste. Spin-network nodes are quanta of space and carry no qualities except geometry. The commentarial size ladder (§4.2) measures the paramāṇu against a chariot-dust mote, which presupposes a background of lengths. That is exactly the background loop quantum gravity denies.
  4. Layer. The correspondence holds at the sub-commentary layer. At the canonical layer, space is a cavity with extent: ear-holes, a well being dug, an opening. A cavity is volume-like, not face-like. So the canon's space corresponds, if to anything, to a region, not to a link. The delimitation reading enters with the commentary's characterization of the space element as delimiting matter (§4.3), and the between-kalāpas reading is completed only in the manual and sub-commentary, more than a millennium after the canon was compiled.
  5. Open space. The Kathāvatthu commentary calls open space (ajaṭākāsa) a mere concept. The Atthasālinī reads otherwise: on its reading, the Dhammasaṅgaṇī's space element is unentangled space, a material phenomenon (§7). Loop quantum gravity has no space without the network: a region with no nodes has no geometry at all. On the Kathāvatthu commentary's reading the two may look alike here, but the likeness is loose. One says that open space is a designation; the other says there is nothing there to designate. On the Atthasālinī's reading there is no likeness at all, since open space is then a material phenomenon.
  6. Opposite incidence. A spin-network link is a face incident to both grains: each grain's polyhedron has it as one of its own faces, and the area belongs to the geometry of both. The Vibhāvinī's delimiter is untouched by both kalāpas (tehi sayaṃ asamphuṭṭhoyeva) and a constituent of neither. "Belongs to neither neighbour" covers both only because it is vague. Said exactly, the link is shared and the delimiter is excluded, which are opposite relations. What the two have in common is only that the boundary is not itself a minimal unit.
  7. Counted, but not ultimate. The delimiter is one of the twenty-eight material phenomena, but it is not an ultimate reality (Bodhi 1993), and on Karunadasa's reading (1967) it is "nothing but the mere limitation of matter". The link in loop quantum gravity is as real as anything in the theory. So the Theravāda "something" between kalāpas is a named something, not a real unit, and the row's contrast with the Kashmiri nothing rests on the naming and counting.

4.7 · What would falsify this row

4.8 · The grain's one textual size, carried outward

The rows above compare shapes. This one puts a number on the grain, because the Mahāṭīkā's line (§4.2) invites it, and the result is a collision. The comparison needs four steps the texts do not take, all of them this paper's: an aṅgula (finger-breadth) in meters, taken here as 1.7–2.5 cm; the ladder read as metrology, though it was taught as a device for seeing small faults as large (abh02a.att.xml:6333); a uniform size carried from bodily matter to external matter, though every textual size concerns the body (the Mahāṭīkā's "in one body", Ledi's embryo, the sub-commentary's eye); and "forty-nine" read one way or another.

The ladder gives 7³ × 36⁴ = 576,108,288 paramāṇu to the aṅgula, so one paramāṇu is about 3–4 × 10⁻¹¹ m (d7_ladder, d7_sizes). Rutherford's 1911 scattering law, which treats the central charge as a point, has an α particle reaching about 3.4 × 10⁻¹⁴ m, or 34 femtometers (fm), of the center; the proton's charge radius is 0.84 fm (Pohl et al. 2010); Hofstadter's electron scattering (1956) maps charge distributions at the femtometer scale.

  READING OF ONE KALĀPA                       SIZE, fm            AGAINST 34 fm     AGAINST 0.84 fm
  ──────────────────────────────────────────  ──────────────────  ────────────────  ────────────────
  Mahāṭīkā: kalāpa = paramāṇu                 29,500 – 43,400     ≈ 870 – 1,280 ×   ≈ 35,000 – 52,000 ×
  "49" as an equality, read by volume         8,100 – 11,900      ≈ 240 – 350 ×     ≈ 9,600 – 14,000 ×
  "49" as an equality, read linearly          600 – 890           ≈ 18 – 26 ×       ≈ 720 – 1,050 ×
  Ledi as he wrote it: at most paramāṇu/49,   no size             no collision      no collision
    no lower size

The size collision has a weakness of its own: if magnitudes are designations (§2), a clash of magnitudes might be set aside. The count does not have that weakness. A gold nucleus, about 7 fm in radius and so wholly inside one kalāpa on every sized reading above, holds 197 individuated nucleons. A kalāpa of external matter is a pure octad, with eight members, and the plurality of dhammas is what the teachers' method leaves real. If what is individuated inside a kalāpa must be one of its members (this paper's premise), 197 cannot fit in eight (d7_count_collision). No anchor in the stated range clears this.

The ladder also misses its own visible rung. The commentary says the aṇu (thirty-six paramāṇu) appears whirling in a sunbeam through a crack (abh02a.att.xml:6333). On the same anchors an aṇu is about 1–1.6 nm, some six to nine hundred times smaller than the roughly one-micrometer dust that makes a visible sunbeam (the threshold is a rough figure of this paper's). "Swirls" (vaṭṭi vaṭṭi) describes groups, not one aṇu, and nanometer particles still do not form them. This extends the comparison the formal-abhidhamma run the outside world made at the ladder's louse and nit rungs.

Verdict: a collision with a reading, again. The Mahāṭīkā's line, taken as the metric size of one kalāpa and carried to external matter, collides with measured nuclear structure. Taken as Ledi takes it, it does not, and then no grain of extent for matter follows from the texts. Space has a smallest portion only as a designation: the commentary's paramāṇu is ākāsakoṭṭhāsika, and the Anudīpanī glosses that as placed by people in a space-portion (manussehi ākāsakoṭṭhāse ṭhapito, e0401n.nrf.xml:1261). Ledi's exit is the tradition's own and was not built for this comparison: he wrote before these measurements were made. It leaves the row weaker, which fits §4.5: the grain survives as what the boundary presupposes, with no length of its own.

What would falsify this subsection. A text giving a kalāpa of external matter a size; a text making the Mahāṭīkā's line a measurement and not a teaching device; or a reading on which what is individuated in a nucleus is no plurality of dhammas at all, which would remove the count collision. The last is easy to supply, and that is a limit of the collision, stated in §12.


5 · Row 4 — Ratio: Time as a Count

5.1 · Physics primer: a duration is a number of steps

Recall from §3.1 that in a causal set the proper time between two related events is proportional to the length of the longest chain between them. There is no clock apart from counting. Two durations can be compared by comparing chain lengths, and the ratio is meaningful even though no unit of time is ever introduced. (Converting to seconds needs the sprinkling density, one element per Planck volume. The ratio does not need it.)

5.2 · The Abhidhamma side

Three sub-moments per mind-moment. The manual (ch. 4 §8, abh07t.nrf.xml:1229): "Uppādaṭhitibhaṅgavasena khaṇattayaṃ ekacittakkhaṇaṃ nāma" — a mind-moment consists of three sub-moments: arising, presence, dissolution.

Seventeen mind-moments per material phenomenon. The next line: "Tāni pana sattarasa cittakkhaṇāni rūpadhammānamāyū" — seventeen such mind-moments are the lifespan of material phenomena. The manual then shows where seventeen comes from. It is the length of the longest process by which a sense object is known: one past life-continuum moment, two vibrations of the life-continuum, and fourteen moments of the process itself: "cuddasa vīthicittuppādā, dve bhavaṅgacalanāni, pubbevātītakamekacittakkhaṇanti katvā sattarasa cittakkhaṇāni paripūrenti" (§11, :1241). Seventeen is a consistency condition. A physical object must last as long as the longest process that cognises it.

The commentary gives the same figure in its own words: while matter persists, sixteen minds arise and cease, and it ceases with the seventeenth (rūpe dharanteyeva soḷasa cittāni uppajjitvā nirujjhanti. Taṃ pana sattarasamena cittena saddhiṃ nirujjhati, Sammohavinodanī, abh02a.att.xml:413). Its simile has a short-legged and a long-legged man walking together, sixteen steps to one, and its lesson is stated first: "matter cannot go on leaving mind behind, nor mind leaving matter; the going of both is of one measure" (rūpaṃ pana arūpaṃ arūpaṃ vā rūpaṃ ohāya pavattituṃ na sakkonti. Dvinnampi ekappamāṇāva pavatti, abh02a.att.xml:417).

Fifty-one sub-moments, with exceptions. The sub-commentary: "Visuṃ visuṃ pana ekapaññāsa cittakkhaṇāni honti. Rūpadhammānanti viññattilakkhaṇarūpavajjānaṃ rūpadhammānaṃ" — counted separately, they are fifty-one; "material phenomena" means those other than the intimations and the characteristic phenomena (abh07t.nrf.xml:4837). It then states the exceptions. The two intimations (bodily and vocal) last one mind-moment. Of the characteristics, arising and impermanence match the mind-moment's arising and dissolution sub-moments, and decay lasts forty-nine sub-moments. There is no single material clock.

Seventeen, sixteen and a third, or sixteen: the count is disputed. The Sammohavinodanī holds two rules. It first dates kamma-born matter by one stated "because it came in the [older] commentary" (aṭṭhakathāyaṃ āgatattā vuttaṃ): matter arisen at one mind's arising sub-moment ceases at another's (abh02a.att.xml:421), sixteen mind-moments and a third. It then rejects that rule as conflicting with the canonical Yamaka (imāya pāḷiyā virujjhati, :429) and replaces it with seventeen: matter arisen with the rebirth-linking mind ceases with the seventeenth, and matter arisen at that mind's presence sub-moment ceases at the arising of the eighteenth (:433). The Vibhaṅga Mūlaṭīkā reads the passage so (abh02t.tik.xml:305), and finds both the seventeen and the older "sixteen and a third" (yā ca aṭṭhakathāyaṃ tatiyabhāgādhikasoḷasacittakkhaṇāyukatā, :309) at odds with the commentary's own account of death and rebirth-linking, in which eleven mind-moments of an object's life have passed and five remain (abh02a.att.xml:2889; e0102n.mul.xml:4045). Its Anuṭīkā concludes "sixteen only" (abh02t.tik.xml:4933), and four lines later speaks of "sixteen or seventeen" (soḷasahi sattarasahi vā cittakkhaṇehi, :4937). The Vibhāvinī reports the sixteen as the view of "some" (keci) and rejects it as without substance (tayidamasāraṃ), citing the replacement rule, and reads any sixteen as a count of the moments fit to condition mind (abh07t.nrf.xml:4845); Ledi Sayadaw finds that rejection "not good" (taṃ na sundaraṃ, e0301n.nrf.xml:2745). Seventeen is the manual's figure and the Vibhāvinī's, not a settled one.

The presence sub-moment is disputed too. The Vibhāvinī reports that "some reject the presence moment of consciousness" (keci pana cittassa ṭhitikkhaṇaṃ paṭisedhenti), because the canonical Yamaka names only arising and dissolution (bhaṅguppādāva kathitā, na ṭhitikkhaṇo, abh07t.nrf.xml:4833). It names no one; the cross-reference to the Vibhaṅga Mūlaṭīkā beside the passage is the edition's. The Mūlaṭīkā does raise the question in its own voice, on the same ground: "whether it exists or not is to be examined" (so ca atthi natthīti vicāretabbo, abh02t.tik.xml:313). Sumaṅgala rejects the dissent, citing the commentary's three sub-moments. Without presence, this paper's arithmetic gives 17 × 2 = 34 in place of 51 (the dissent states no count), and decay's forty-nine sub-moments would be undefined.

An absolute scale, named but not timed. The Vibhaṅga commentary says of feeling, a mental factor present in every consciousness, that "in the moment of a finger-snap it arises and ceases a hundred thousand koṭi times" (ekaccharakkhaṇe koṭisatasahassasaṅkhyā uppajjitvā nirujjhati, abh02a.att.xml:533). The texts say what a finger-snap is without giving it a duration. The Aṅguttara commentary names it by a gesture, "the mere making of a sound by striking two fingers" (dve aṅguliyo paharitvā saddakaraṇamattanti attho, s0401a.att.xml:1119). A Pāli grammar, the Payogasiddhi, makes it the unit of vowel length: "the short time is the time called a finger-snap or an eye-blink; by it the short vowel has one measure" (rassakālo nāma accharāsaṅghāto akkhinimmilanasaṅkhāto vā kālo, tena ekamatto rasso, e0807n.nrf.xml:205). Each fixes a unit of reckoning, not a number of seconds. This paper takes a finger-snap as about a tenth of a second, and that assumption is its own.

The texts state the rate of mind itself as round lower bounds in four works, not as one number:

Work (layer)LocusWordsReading
Saṃyutta commentary, on SN 12.61 (commentary)s0302a.att.xml:1463ekasmiñhi accharākkhaṇe anekāni cittakoṭisatasahassāni uppajjantimany × 10¹² mind-moments per snap
Milindapañha, quoted on the next line of the same commentarys0518m.nrf.xml:2838; s0302a.att.xml:1467ekaccharākkhaṇe pavattacittassa ettakā vīhī lakkhaṃ ṭhapīyamānā … parikkhayaṃ pariyādānaṃ gaccheyyuṃmore minds in a snap than grains in over a hundred cartloads of rice
Sāratthadīpanī, on the Vinaya (sub-commentary)vin01t2.tik.xml:341accharāsaṅghātamatte khaṇe anekakoṭisahassacittappavattisambhavatomany × 10¹⁰ per snap
Dhammasaṅgaṇī Anuṭīkā (sub-commentary)abh04t.nrf.xml:821accharāsaṅghātakkhaṇena anekakoṭisaṅkhāya cittuppattiyāmany × 10⁷ per snap

The readings take koṭi as 10⁷, satasahassa as 10⁵ and sahassa as 10³; aneka, "not one", makes each a floor. Read strictly as "at least two", it would put the first floor at 2 × 10¹², above the commentary's own flat 10¹² for feeling, which arises and ceases with its mind; so either aneka is not a strict floor of two, or two of Buddhaghosa's commentaries differ by a factor of two. This paper reads the figures as round orders of magnitude. None of the four works states a ceiling. On the tenth-of-a-second assumption, the floors put a mind-moment at or below about 10⁻¹³ to 10⁻⁸ seconds, far below any timescale on which perception is measured.

The texts deny that this succession is seen by the reasoner and by "others", not by everyone. The Dīgha commentary says the speculative reasoner of DN 1 "does not see the breaking up of mind" (cittassa bhedaṃ na passati), because each mind-moment ceases only after conditioning the next, and so takes mind to fly on elsewhere like a bird (s0101a.att.xml:2245): a diagnosis of his error. The Sāratthadīpanī says the order of a Buddha's teaching "is not discerned by others", while the order of several monks' questions "is discerned by one so wise" (pucchanavāro tādisassa paññavato paññāyati … Buddhānaṃ pana desanāvāro aññesaṃ na paññāyateva, vin01t2.tik.xml:341), and the Vibhaṅga Anuṭīkā reserves true knowledge of the elements to the Tathāgata (nānādhātūsu tathāgatasseva yathābhūtañāṇaṃ, abh02t.tik.xml:4937). So the tradition does give the mind-moment an outside scale, the snap, and the offer cannot be taken as a measurement. (Three of the four floors were supplied by the refuter of the formal-abhidhamma run rate-of-mind control, 2026-09-30, runs/2026-09-30-rate-of-mind-control/RUN.md.)

5.3 · The correspondence, and its surviving form

The Abhidhamma measures the lifetime of matter in mind-moments. This paper counts the lifetime by its elements, as the manual does (sattarasa cittakkhaṇāni, seventeen moments), because each mind-moment is itself a stretch of time. A causal-set chain is conventionally counted by its links, since its elements are points; the difference of one does not matter at large counts, but it does at seventeen.

Two cases, which the texts treat differently. An earlier version of this paper had matter "timed by the mind's chain". The texts support that where a stream exists, and not where none does.

So the general statement of seventeen is not tied to a present mind. The Vibhāvinī glosses the manual's "seventeen mind-moments" as "moments like the moments of seventeen minds" (sattarasannaṃ cittānaṃ khaṇāni viya khaṇāni, abh07t.nrf.xml:4837; likewise "one mind-moment", :4849), and Ledi Sayadaw calls the division of one moment into mind's and matter's a conceptual construction (kappanāvasena, e0301n.nrf.xml:2749). That is the reading of the seventeen as a unit of reckoning, a duration counted in mind-moment lengths. It is not the only reading open: the Vibhaṅga Anuṭīkā derives matter's longer life from its being made known by mind, in sixteen or seventeen mind-moments (abh02t.tik.xml:4937), which leaves the reading that the count describes matter as cognised, and says nothing of matter no mind cognises.

Where a stream exists, the texts date its mind-born and kamma-born matter on its own mind-moments, sub-moment by sub-moment, without making mind that matter's condition. Where none exists, no text counts matter in mind-moments: the mindless beings' material series is timed by kamma's momentum in aeons, and a sub-commentary makes the mind-moment a unit. What survives of the causal-set comparison is generic: a duration stated as a count of steps (§9).

The row's name, ratio, needs one correction. The ratio is 17 : 1, a material lifetime against one mind-moment, but both terms are measured in the same unit. Matter has no chain of its own in S, so the row gives a ratio of durations, not a ratio of two chain lengths.

A second reckoning, and how the texts relate it. Asked how long an aeon (kappa) is, the Buddha answers that it is not easy to count in "so many years, or so many hundreds of years …" (so na sukaro saṅkhātuṃ ettakāni vassāni iti vā, ettakāni vassasatāni iti vā) and gives the simile of a mountain a league on each side, wiped with a cloth once a century, which would wear away before the aeon ends (SN 15.5, s0302m.mul.xml:3529–:3533; past aeons are "not easy to count", SN 15.8, :3565). The aeon is not counted in years; the simile sets it against a process timed in centuries. The texts do relate it to the mind-moment, in the mindless beings' case, and the relation is divergence. Since "the usage 'time' rests only on the occurrence of phenomena", the Paṭṭhāna Mūlaṭīkā finds "no time-interval" between the death before that existence and the rebirth-linking after it, for "the occurrence of matter makes no interval in the occurrence of mind, because it is another series" (kālantaratā natthi … na ca rūpadhammappavatti arūpadhammappavattiyā antaraṃ karoti aññasantānattā, abh03t.tik.xml:4309); its Anuṭīkā names the objection this answers, "how then is it said, 'having passed five hundred aeons'?" (abh05t.nrf.xml:4641). The Paṭṭhāna commentary had already rejected a view of "the teachers" that contiguity means nearness in time, because the attainment before cessation is still the contiguity condition of the fruition after it, and granted that "there is no nearness in time there" (kālānantaratā natthi, abh03a.att.xml:7697); the Vibhāvinī follows it and counts the rebirth-linking that arises "even after a time-interval" from the mindless existence the same way (kālantarepi, abh07t.nrf.xml:6653). Ledi Sayadaw: "between two minds, in the non-percipient existence, the person stands without mind for five hundred aeons" (dvinnaṃ cittānaṃ antare asaññasattabhave pañcakappasatāni puggalo acittako tiṭṭhati, e0501n.nrf.xml:233). The two reckonings meet and do not agree: five hundred aeons in one, no interval in the other. As a lens only, the pair recalls relativity's proper time along a worldline and the cosmic time of the expanding (FLRW) cosmologies; nothing in the likeness is a prediction. For this row the divergence settles one point: the aeon is not a second chain for the seventeen to be compared with.

5.4 · Where it breaks

5.5 · What would falsify this row


6 · The Row We Dropped, and Why

The first version of this lens had a fifth row: saṅkhāra, the conditioned as a whole (sabbe saṅkhārā, "all conditioned things"), against Fotini Markopoulou's quantum causal histories. That framework puts quantum state spaces on a causal set, and so joins causal order to quantum structure.

It was cut before drafting, for two reasons.

  1. Category error. Saṅkhāra includes the mental (nāma): consciousness, feeling, perception, volition. Nothing in a spin network or a quantum causal history models mind. A row that maps a category containing mind onto a structure that contains none is not a correspondence with a break. It is a correspondence that breaks everywhere.
  2. No structure added. Every structural feature the row could claim was already in rows 1–4: order in row 1, grains and adjacency in rows 2–3. The row said that the conditioned as a whole resembles order-plus-quanta as a whole. A resemblance with no new structure is decoration: a coherence that feels like evidence and is none.

The neighbour, stated accurately. Markopoulou's 2000 paper assigns a finite-dimensional Hilbert space (a quantum state space) to each event and evolution operators between sets of events. The same paper already notes a problem: the evolution does not see the individual causal relations. It proposes, as an alternative, attaching the Hilbert spaces to the edges (the covering relations) and the operators to the events. On that reading, the state space on an edge from p to q is "the state space of p as seen by q". Hawkins, Markopoulou and Sahlmann (2003) then revised the definition. They put operator algebras on the events and made each causal relation carry a completely positive map, the most general quantum transformation, so that the evolution respects every individual relation.

There is an irony here, and it is recorded rather than used. Both moves make the relation a carrier of structure. That fits the Paṭṭhāna's relation-first typing better than the original event-first definition did, but it does not rescue the row. A typed relation carrying a completely positive map is still not a relation of object, predominance or kamma.


7 · Why a Theravāda Space, and Not Nāgārjuna's

A widely read recent meeting of Buddhist thought and physics is Carlo Rovelli's reading of Nāgārjuna (cross-tradition: Madhyamaka) beside relational quantum mechanics, in Helgoland. On the relational view, a system has properties only relative to another system. On Nāgārjuna's, nothing has own-being (svabhāva): everything is empty of intrinsic existence. Rovelli finds the two congenial.

This paper does not use that pairing, for a reason of structure and not of loyalty. Madhyamaka denies own-being (svabhāva) to every dharma, so it admits no ultimately real units to put in adjacency. The Theravāda Abhidhamma is realist about dharmas: its moments, its material phenomena and its conditions are real events. A discrete theory needs discrete units and relations among them. The Theravāda supplies both, so of the two it is the framework that can be compared structurally with causal sets and spin networks. It is also the framework whose space can be put beside a link: space as the delimitation between real units. One point weakens the contrast and should be stated. The boundary at the center of the adjacency row is defined as lacking own-nature: it is one of the ten kinds of matter the manual classes as not concretely produced (anipphanna; delimitation, the two intimations, the three mutabilities and the four characteristics, abh07t.nrf.xml:2117–:2121). The units are real (nipphanna, concretely produced); their delimitation is not a unit. So the argument for the Theravāda over Madhyamaka rests on the units, not on the boundary: a discrete comparison needs real units, and of these two frameworks only the Theravāda supplies them. It is not the only Buddhist school that does; the Sarvāstivāda of §4.4, also realist about dharmas, supplies them too. The Madhyamaka comparison is a comparison of attitudes toward relation. It is real, but it is a different comparison.

The institution's ruling, stated plainly. The institution publishing this paper has ruled, for its own purposes, that delimiting space (paricchedākāsa) is conditioned and only nibbāna is unconditioned, and that the place named space on its own organizational map of four bodies (§11) is delimiting space: never open space, and never the unconditioned. The ruling follows the manual and its sub-commentaries in reading the space element as delimiting matter, and it declines the Sarvāstivāda reading of ākāśa as unconditioned. Its ground is the boundary relation. On that map, space is the between of the four and exists only as their boundary, which makes it delimiting space whatever the texts below say of open space; in the texts' own terms, delimiting space has the matter it delimits as its proximate cause (§4.3).

The texts bear on the ruling at three points, and at the third they disagree.

  1. The canon's Kathāvatthu refutes "space is unconditioned" (VI.6, §460–461, abh03m3.mul.xml:7325–:7345).
  2. At the close of the same debate (§462, abh03m3.mul.xml:7349) the Theravādin also declines to call space conditioned without qualification. The Kathāvatthu commentary treats §§460–462 in a single paragraph, says that the rest of the debate is plain in meaning (sesamettha uttānatthamevā), and does not comment on that refusal (abh03a.att.xml:4145). Reading the refusal through the commentary's three spaces, as an earlier version of this section did, is this paper's reading and not the commentary's.
  3. That paragraph names three spaces. It classes delimiting space as conditioned, and the other two, the space left by removing a meditation disk (kasiṇa) and unentangled, open space, as mere concepts (paññattimattā). For open space the classification is disputed. The Atthasālinī reads the Dhammasaṅgaṇī's space element, "untouched by the four great elements" (§637, abh01m.mul.xml:5473), as unentangled space (nijjaṭākāsaṃva kathitaṃ, abh01a.att.xml:8465). The Vibhaṅga Mūlaṭīkā reads the Sammohavinodanī's gloss on the same words in the Vibhaṅga as speaking of unentangled space and not of the space left by the disk (abh02t.tik.xml:653, on abh02a.att.xml:1093). On that reading open space is the space element itself, which the Dhammasaṅgaṇī lists among material phenomena (rūpaṃ ākāsadhātu), and not a concept. The sub-commentaries on the Dhammasaṅgaṇī and on the manual gloss the same words as delimitation (abh01t.tik.xml:2177; abh07t.nrf.xml:5821). Ledi Sayadaw sets the commentary's reading beside a sub-commentary's, and his own gloss of the words is the delimiting one (e0301n.nrf.xml:4077).

So "open space is a mere concept" is the Kathāvatthu commentary's reading. The ruling keeps it as a second support, labeled as one of two readings, and its ground, the boundary relation, does not depend on it. On either reading, as this paper reads them, no space is left unconditioned: a concept is not an unconditioned phenomenon, and the Dhammasaṅgaṇī calls all matter conditioned (sabbaṃ rūpaṃ … saṅkhatameva, §594, abh01m.mul.xml:5285). The text nearest the other option is the Milindapañha, in which Nāgasena names space and nibbāna as the two things in the world born neither of kamma, nor of a cause, nor of temperature (s0518m.nrf.xml:5644), without calling either unconditioned in that passage. The Sarvāstivāda draws a comparable line: beside its unconditioned ākāśa (Kośa I.5), it names a conditioned space element, the cavity (I.28), as §4.4 records.


8 · The Strongest Objection, Carried

Objection. "The Abhidhamma is a phenomenology: an analysis of what appears in experience, made for the purpose of liberation. Quantum gravity is a theory of what spacetime is. The kalāpa contains colour, odour and taste, which are qualities of matter as sensed. The Kathāvatthu commentary says that space between two trees is known by the mind, from the absence of visible matter, not seen by the eye. A comparison of the two frameworks compares an account of knowing with an account of being. Any shared shape is a coincidence of two different questions."

What survives it. Most of the objection stands, and the paper does not answer it away. Every row compares formal shape: an acyclic relation, a boundary located at an adjacency, a duration expressed as a count. Shape is what two frameworks with different subject matter can share without sharing a subject, and it is all this paper claims they share. The objection does not show that the shapes differ. It shows that shared shape proves nothing about shared subject matter, and the paper agrees. What the objection does remove is any reading of the lens as evidence that the Abhidhamma knew physics, or that physics vindicates the Abhidhamma. Neither reading was offered, and the objection makes sure neither can be taken.


9 · The Counter-Argument to This Paper's Strongest Claim

The strongest claim is the adjacency row (§4.5). Against it: the idea that a boundary lives at the adjacency is not specific to loop quantum gravity. It holds in any cellular picture of extended stuff: a cell complex, a Voronoi tessellation, a chessboard, and Regge calculus (Regge 1961), in which curved spacetime is approximated by flat simplices glued along shared faces, and the geometry is fixed by the edge lengths of neighbouring cells. The Western literature on boundaries has argued the ownership question directly. When two bodies touch, does the boundary belong to one of them (Bolzano), to neither (a view the literature traces to Leonardo), or is it two coincident boundaries, one belonging to each (Brentano)? (Varzi's survey; Casati and Varzi 1999, ch. 5.) The "neither" view is the nearest Western neighbour of the manual's "a constituent of neither". Brentano's is a contrast: his coincident boundaries are dependent parts of the bodies they bound, which is the opposite of the Vibhāvinī's delimiter, untouched by both. Aristotle defined place as the innermost boundary of the containing body (Physics IV.4), a boundary account of where that is two millennia old and owes nothing to quanta. The Kośa's debate (§4.4) shows the Indian schools arguing the same question in the first millennium. If the shared shape is generic, then the match with loop quantum gravity specifically is weaker than the table makes it look.

What loop quantum gravity adds to the generic picture is that the adjacency carries a quantised magnitude, and that volume is derived from it. Those are exactly the two features the Abhidhamma lacks (§4.6, breaks 1 and 2). So the part of the row that is loop-quantum-gravity-specific is the part that fails, and the part that holds is generic. The row survives only in this form: the Theravāda sub-commentary's answer to "what is between minimal units?" has the shape of the answer loop quantum gravity gives, and not the shape of the answer an earlier Indian school gave. The paper does not refute the generic reading. It claims no more than that.

The same counter-argument, run on the ratio row (§5.3). Against it: every discrete clock counts steps, so "a duration is a count" is not specific to causal sets. The causal-set-specific features are three: proper time is the length of the longest chain, whichever chain that is; the relation between chain length and proper time is statistical, holding on average over a random sprinkling; and there is no time apart from the order. The first two are among §5.4's breaks, and the third is left open (§3.4). So, as with the adjacency row, what holds for certain is generic: a duration stated as a count of steps (§5.3). The third feature is also shared, on one reading, by loop quantum gravity, which takes no time as basic either (§5.4), so it does not separate the two programs.

The same counter-argument, run on causal sets and space. The adjacency row was set against loop quantum gravity alone. Against a causal set it has no counterpart, and the reason is structural. In a causal set, "spacelike simply means unrelated" (§3.1) [X]: for any two elements neither of which lies in the other's past, the order relates them in no way, whatever their separation. A set of mutually unrelated elements is an antichain, and a causal set gives an antichain no structure of its own. §4.5 reads the kalāpas present together as playing that part. The Vibhāvinī gives the neighbors in such a group something between them, a counted delimiter, even where they touch (§4.3) [S]. The row's question, what is between neighbors present together?, presupposes a relation among them. A causal set has none, so the question is not answered there either way, and §4.4's table takes no causal-set row. Spatial notions are not absent from the theory. They are derived from the causal relations, which join an element only to elements outside its antichain: Rideout and Wallden (2009) propose such a construction, and present spatial distance as the harder case for the theory (abstract, as summarized), and Sorkin's slogan order plus number (§3.1) says the same of geometry as a whole [X]. The texts also derive the between from something prior, its proximate cause being the matter delimited (§4.6, break 1) [S]. So both start from something other than space, from opposite bases: matter in the texts, an order with no matter in it for the causal set. What they share is the generic negative that space is not basic. Graded as an extension with causal set theory named, never as agreement.

Three limits. (1) Adding a co-presence relation to a causal set would have to be frame-independent to keep its Lorentz invariance, and co-presence is not; this is the same difficulty as the relativity of simultaneity against presentism, which this paper does not take up (§11). (2) Bombelli, Henson and Sorkin (2006) prove that no equivariant measurable map takes a sprinkling to spacetime directions, even locally (abstract, as summarized), so a neighbor structure built from the sprinkling cannot pick out a direction. A primitive added to a causal set is not that structure, and whether it escapes the theorem is a question for a physics reader, owed (§11). (3) The finding concerns primitives. It says that the causal set's primitive vocabulary has no term in which the row's question can be put. It does not say that the theory cannot recover neighborhood, which Rideout and Wallden and others attempt.


10 · What Would Falsify These Findings — Collected

RowThe findingFalsified by
1 Orderthe earlier→later sub-relation S, over condition-modes, is acyclic (by selection); a strict order, not yet a causal set, can be read over it; S also orders moments of different streams; the rest is extra typinga member of S with the conditioned arising at or before the condition, in any layer; cross-moment kamma with a present or future relatum; an implied temporal order S cannot connect (engaged in a narrowed form between streams, §3.4; open within a stream)
2–3 Adjacencyboth put the unit of spatial boundary at the adjacency between minimal units, and neither makes it a unit; the shared part is generic; the between is matter's and never mind's, for the tradition's own reasona text making delimiting matter a kalāpa constituent, or placing space inside a cluster; a text with two moments of one stream present at once, with mind given shape, or with space delimiting mental phenomena; a formulation of loop quantum gravity in which area between adjacent grains is not carried by their adjacency; a reading of the Vibhāvinī's space as mere absence (partly engaged, §4.7)
4 Ratiomatter dated on a stream's own moments where there is one, a unit where there is none; only the generic part survives, a duration as a count of steps; the aeon meets the mind-moment only as divergencea text timing matter independently of mind-moments; a text counting the mindless beings' matter, or external matter, in some present mind's moments; a text counting the aeon in mind-moments; seventeen shown to be observed rather than derived
The scale (§5.2)the snap is named, not timed; the rate is round lower bounds in four works, with no ceilinga text giving the finger-snap a duration, or the rate an upper bound
The status of continuity (§2)relative length, number, shape and age are designations for mind and matter on the teachers' reported method; the mind-only rows constrain no matter; santati of the mental stream is not a continuuma canonical or commentarial text making length or number real by own-nature; a mind-only row shown to entail a material claim; a text giving mental moments no immediate successor
The grain's size (§4.2, §4.8)the count follows from time, and the size does not; the Mahāṭīkā's size, read metrically and carried outward, collides by count and by size; Ledi's bound escapes, leaving no grain of extenta text sizing a kalāpa of external matter; a text making the Mahāṭīkā's line a measurement; a reading on which a nucleus holds no plurality of dhammas; the Mahāṭīkā's reading found to bear a sense Ledi's objection does not touch
The sub-moment bound (§5.4)at or below about 2.6 × 10⁻²⁵ s, if the Z is a series (ours)a corrected earliest-change argument under A64; a text making the sub-moment a fixed duration; the Z's width revised
The dropped rowsaṅkhāra ↔ quantum causal histories adds no structurea structural feature of quantum causal histories with a Paṭṭhāna counterpart not already in rows 1–4
Time and succession against both programs (§5.4)the negative on time (no basic time) is shared by loop quantum gravity on one reading and by causal sets, so it separates neither; neither takes a per-stream succession as basica formulation of either program with a worldline's succession, with immediate successors, as a primitive; a text making time a basic quantity; a text on which the succession is itself designated; a reading of loop quantum gravity on which time is basic (the program's own dispute)
Space against causal sets (§9)a causal set has no relation among mutually unrelated elements, so the adjacency row's question cannot be put to it; both derive space from something prior, on opposite basesa causal-set formulation with a primitive relation among spacelike elements; a physics reader's showing that an added co-presence relation escapes the frame-dependence difficulty and the Bombelli–Henson–Sorkin theorem

11 · Stake, and What Was and Was Not Done

The authors' stake. The authors write from within the Theravāda. The institution publishing this paper grounds its values in the Pāli canon, has ruled the Theravāda reading of space over the Sarvāstivāda one, and uses the word space on an organisational map of its own. Nothing in this paper bears on that map, and the ruling was made so that the map would not borrow a predicate it should not have. There is a pull, for authors in this position, to see the tradition anticipate frontier physics; the founder's own question began as a hope that the Abhidhamma might hold the bridge between the discrete and the smooth. The pull was acted on, and caught. An adversarial review before any prose dropped a row, merged two and narrowed the order row; outside review caught summaries that outran their own sections; and the 2026-09-30 revision withdrew three statements of the deposited text: that matter is "timed by the mind's chain" (§5.3), that nothing in S orders moments of different streams (§3.4), and that the finger-snap figure is one rhetorical number (§5.2). The 2026-10-06 revision withdrew a fourth: that the space ruling of §7 follows the texts at each point, when the commentary's classification of open space is disputed within the tradition. The 2026-11-03 revision withdrew a fifth: that the kalāpa's identification with the paramāṇu is "later exegesis, common in modern summaries" (§4.2), when a sub-commentary makes it and Ledi Sayadaw declines it. Its source run was scored on whether it would report the collision of §4.8; that collision was foreseeable once the question named the size, so the run tests reporting and not discovery, and its refuter killed two of its first statements ("three voices", which are two authors, and a collision "on every textual size", which Ledi's bound escapes) and cut a bound by fifty-one times. The sibling paper's first framing made the same kind of error in the other direction. The reversals are part of the result.

Done:

Not done:


12 · Honest Limits


13 · Close

The Kathāvatthu commentary gives a small example. A person looks at two trees. The eye sees the trees. The mind, finding no matter between them, knows "space". Loop quantum gravity, asked where the space is between two grains, also answers between, and puts a number on it, which the text does not. The shared part is the generic one (§9). The two answers share that shape and have two subjects. This paper records the shape and marks the boundary between the subjects, which, as in the text it reads, belongs to neither side.


Cross-Venue References

VenueIdentifier
Primary canonical<https://thonly.org/research/abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity>
GitHub<https://github.com/thonly/publications/blob/main/defensive-publications/abhidhamma-and-discrete-quantum-gravity.md>
Sibling paper<https://thonly.org/research/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time>
Census pre-registration (public)thonly/publications commit 7348ba2, timestamps/census/physics-lens-prereg.md
Sibling paper (the Paṭṭhāna's relations)<https://thonly.org/research/patthana-typed-causation-vocabulary>
Lean 4 formalisation (public, CC0)<https://github.com/SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma> (kala/Time.lean, kala/Axioms.lean; runs/2026-10-14-the-continuum-bridge/Bridge.lean); software concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23067241

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the Vipassana Research Institute for the Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana texts; the GRETIL project and the editors of its Abhidharmakośabhāṣya e-text; and the physicists whose lectures and primers are written to be read by people outside the field. The reading of the sources, the adversarial review and the drafting were done with Miss Aquarius, the name under which this institution discloses its AI collaboration.


Citations

Physics

  1. Bombelli, L., Lee, J., Meyer, D. & Sorkin, R.D. (1987). "Space-time as a causal set." Physical Review Letters 59: 521–524.
  2. Brightwell, G. & Gregory, R. (1991). "Structure of random discrete spacetime." Physical Review Letters 66(3): 260–263.
  3. Rideout, D.P. & Sorkin, R.D. (2000). "A classical sequential growth dynamics for causal sets." Physical Review D 61: 024002. arXiv:gr-qc/9904062.
  4. Sorkin, R.D. (2007). "Relativity theory does not imply that the future already exists: a counterexample." In V. Petkov (ed.), Relativity and the Dimensionality of the World, Springer. arXiv:gr-qc/0703098.
  5. Dowker, F. (2022/2023). "Causal Set Quantum Gravity and the Hard Problem of Consciousness." arXiv:2209.07653.
  6. Wüthrich, C. & Callender, C. (2017). "What Becomes of a Causal Set?" British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 68(3): 907–925. arXiv:1502.00018.
  7. Rovelli, C. & Smolin, L. (1995). "Discreteness of area and volume in quantum gravity." Nuclear Physics B 442: 593–619; erratum B456: 753. arXiv:gr-qc/9411005.
  8. Ashtekar, A. & Lewandowski, J. (1997). "Quantum theory of geometry I: Area operators." Classical and Quantum Gravity 14: A55–A81. arXiv:gr-qc/9602046.
  9. Loll, R. (1996). "Spectrum of the volume operator in quantum gravity." Nuclear Physics B 460: 143–154. arXiv:gr-qc/9511030. With Loll, R. (1995). "The volume operator in discretized quantum gravity." Physical Review Letters 75: 3048–3051. arXiv:gr-qc/9506014 (the three-valent result, which the 1996 paper restates).
  10. Rovelli, C. & Upadhya, P. (1998). "Loop quantum gravity and quanta of space: a primer." arXiv:gr-qc/9806079.
  11. Rovelli, C. (2011). "Zakopane lectures on loop gravity." arXiv:1102.3660.
  12. Bianchi, E., Doná, P. & Speziale, S. (2011). "Polyhedra in loop quantum gravity." Physical Review D 83: 044035. arXiv:1009.3402.
  13. Markopoulou, F. & Smolin, L. (1997). "Causal evolution of spin networks." Nuclear Physics B 508: 409–430. arXiv:gr-qc/9702025.
  14. Markopoulou, F. (2000). "Quantum causal histories." Classical and Quantum Gravity 17: 2059–2072. arXiv:hep-th/9904009.
  15. Hawkins, E., Markopoulou, F. & Sahlmann, H. (2003). "Evolution in quantum causal histories." Classical and Quantum Gravity 20: 3839. arXiv:hep-th/0302111.
  16. Rovelli, C. (2021). Helgoland. Riverhead / Allen Lane (Italian ed. Adelphi, 2020). Chapter on Nāgārjuna.
  17. Hawking, S.W., King, A.R. & McCarthy, P.J. (1976). "A new topology for curved space–time which incorporates the causal, differential, and conformal structures." Journal of Mathematical Physics 17(2): 174–181.
  18. Malament, D.B. (1977). "The class of continuous timelike curves determines the topology of spacetime." Journal of Mathematical Physics 18(7): 1399–1404.
  19. Regge, T. (1961). "General relativity without coordinates." Il Nuovo Cimento 19: 558–571.
  20. Domagala, M. & Lewandowski, J. (2004). "Black-hole entropy from quantum geometry." Classical and Quantum Gravity 21: 5233–5244. arXiv:gr-qc/0407051.
  21. Meissner, K.A. (2004). "Black-hole entropy in loop quantum gravity." Classical and Quantum Gravity 21: 5245–5252. arXiv:gr-qc/0407052.
  22. Ghosh, A. & Mitra, P. (2005). "An improved estimate of black hole entropy in the quantum geometry approach." Physics Letters B 616: 114–117.
  23. Rossi, B. & Hall, D.B. (1941). "Variation of the Rate of Decay of Mesotrons with Momentum." Physical Review 59(3): 223–228. (Read in a scanned copy of the journal pages: <http://supernovae.in2p3.fr/~llg/Enseignements/Agregation/Relativite/biblio/Rossi-et-Hall--1941.pdf>.)
  24. Bailey, J., Borer, K., Combley, F., Drumm, H., Krienen, F., Lange, F., Picasso, E., von Ruden, W., Farley, F.J.M., Field, J.H., Flegel, W. & Hattersley, P.M. (1977). "Measurements of relativistic time dilatation for positive and negative muons in a circular orbit." Nature 268: 301–305. (Primary text not reached; figures checked against 25.)
  25. Lobo, I.P., Pfeifer, C. & Morais, P.H. (2025). "Experimental Bounds on Deformed Muon Lifetime Dilation." Physics Letters B 866: 139511. arXiv:2406.05150v3 (re-analyses the data of 24).

Pāli and Sanskrit sources (Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana edition, VRI tipitaka-xml, unless noted; file:line references are to the romn/ text at commit 05d5d3c)

  1. Dhammasaṅgaṇī §637, the space element (abh01m.mul.xml:5473); §594, all matter conditioned (abh01m.mul.xml:5285); §652, kamma-produced visible form (abh01m.mul.xml:5549).
  2. Vibhaṅga, Dhātuvibhaṅga, the space element; and the modes of existence, including non-percipient existence (abh02m.mul.xml:3685).
  3. Dhātukathā, non-percipient existence as one aggregate (abh03m1.mul.xml:421).
  4. Kathāvatthu III.11 Asaññakathā (abh03m3.mul.xml:5797); VI.6 Ākāsakathā, §460–462 (abh03m3.mul.xml:7325–:7349); VI.7, §463 (abh03m3.mul).
  5. Kathāvatthu-aṭṭhakathā on VI.6–7: the three spaces (abh03a.att.xml:4145); the two trees (abh03a.att.xml:4157).
  6. Paṭṭhāna-aṭṭhakathā: on contiguity and the absence of shape (abh03a.att.xml:7697); on the root condition, kamma-born matter going on without mind, and non-percipient existence as the place of matter (:7857, :7861).
  7. Buddhaghosa. Visuddhimagga ch. XIV, ¶442 (the space element), the kalāpa passages of the second volume, and the death-and-rebirth passage (e0101n.mul, e0102n.mul; e0102n.mul.xml:4045).
  8. Sammohavinodanī (Vibhaṅga-aṭṭhakathā): the size ladder (gloss on aṇumattesu vajjesu); the finger-snap figure for feeling (abh02a.att.xml:533); the lifetime of matter, the two walkers, and the older and replacement rules for dating kamma-born matter (abh02a.att.xml:409–:433); the death-and-rebirth passage (abh02a.att.xml:2889); the external space element (abh02a.att.xml:1093).
  9. Atthasālinī (Dhammasaṅgaṇī-aṭṭhakathā), on internal and external, on time as a designation, and on the space element as unentangled space (abh01a.att.xml:3485, :3721, :8465); and the Dhammasaṅgaṇī Mūlaṭīkā on §637 (abh01t.tik.xml:2177).
  10. Vibhaṅga Mūlaṭīkā and Vibhaṅga Anuṭīkā, on the lifetime of matter, the presence sub-moment and the space element (abh02t.tik.xml:305, :309, :313, :653, :4933, :4937).
  11. Paṭṭhāna Mūlaṭīkā and Paṭṭhāna Anuṭīkā, on contiguity, shapelessness and the time-interval across the mindless existence (abh03t.tik.xml:4305, :4309; abh05t.nrf.xml:4637, :4641).
  12. Anuruddha. Abhidhammatthasaṅgaha chs. 2, 3, 4, 6, 8 (abh07t, bound with the sub-commentary): among others abh07t.nrf.xml:329, :1229–:1241, :1485, :1693, :1957, :2117–:2121, :2169, :2213, :2273, :2277, :2349, :2865, :2873, :2909, :2913.
  13. Sumaṅgala. Abhidhammatthavibhāvinī-ṭīkā on chs. 3, 4, 6, 8 (abh07t): among others abh07t.nrf.xml:4833–:4849, :5553, :5821, :6653.
  14. Vasubandhu. Abhidharmakośabhāṣya ad I.5, I.28, I.43 and II.22, ed. P. Pradhan (2nd ed., 1975), pp. 32–33 for I.43; GRETIL e-text (line references in square brackets are GRETIL's page|line).
  15. Paṭṭhāna, Kusalattika, pañhāvāra (abh03m7.mul): §427 (kamma across moments, abh03m7.mul.xml:6065); the modes of the presence, dissociation and support conditions.
  16. Brahmajāla Sutta (DN 1), the non-percipient beings (s0101m.mul.xml:487).
  17. Saṃyutta Nikāya 15.5 (Pabbata) and 15.8 (Gaṅgā), on the length and number of aeons (s0302m.mul.xml:3529–:3533, :3565).
  18. Sumaṅgalavilāsinī (Dīgha commentary), on the unseen breaking up of mind (s0101a.att.xml:2245); and the Dīgha sub-commentary on DN 1, the mindless beings' material series (s0101t.tik.xml:2053).
  19. Sāratthappakāsinī (Saṃyutta commentary), on SN 12.61, the rate of mind per finger-snap (s0302a.att.xml:1463, :1467).
  20. Manorathapūraṇī (Aṅguttara commentary), the finger-snap as the striking of two fingers (s0401a.att.xml:1119); and the Aṅguttara sub-commentary on AN 1.48, every mind of the same moment (s0401t.tik.xml:1666).
  21. Paramatthajotikā (Suttanipāta commentary), two minds never together (s0505a.att.xml:685).
  22. Sāratthadīpanī-ṭīkā (Vinaya sub-commentary), the rate of mind and the discerned and undiscerned orders (vin01t2.tik.xml:341).
  23. Dhammasaṅgaṇī Anuṭīkā, the rate of mind, and the durations of series (abh04t.nrf.xml:821).
  24. Milindapañha, the rate of mind in rice grains and the seven kinds of mind (s0518m.nrf.xml:2838–:2870); space and nibbāna as born of neither kamma, nor a cause, nor temperature (s0518m.nrf.xml:5644).
  25. Payogasiddhi (a Pāli grammar), the finger-snap as the short-vowel mora (e0807n.nrf.xml:205).
  26. Ledi Sayadaw. Paramatthadīpanī (Saṅgaha-mahāṭīkā), on the count of the lifetime and the unit, and on the two readings of the space element (e0301n.nrf.xml:2745, :2749, :4077); Paṭṭhānuddesa-dīpanī, on the between and on the mindless existence (e0501n.nrf.xml:229, :233).

Other neighbours

  1. Ly, T. & Miss Aquarius (2026). "Causal Set Theory, the Growing Block, and the Buddhist Debate on the Three Times." <https://thonly.org/research/the-vibhajjavadin-view-of-time>.
  2. Ly, T. & Miss Aquarius (2026). "Twenty-Four Kinds of Because: The Paṭṭhāna as a Typed-Causation Vocabulary for AI Alignment," §4.7. <https://thonly.org/research/patthana-typed-causation-vocabulary>.
  3. Ly, T. & Miss Aquarius (2026). Formal Abhidhamma: the Theravāda Abhidhamma in Lean 4 (software, CC0), kala/Time.lean, kala/Axioms.lean, and the run runs/2026-09-30-rate-of-mind-control/. <https://github.com/SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma>; concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23067241.
  4. The Ephemeral Projector — A Comparative Analysis of Quantum Mechanics and Abhidhamma. ResearchGate 397427972.
  5. "Causal Set Theory and Abhidhamma: A Dialogue…", ekasiswanto.wordpress.com, 2026-07-31 (self-labelled AI-generated).
  6. "Kalapa (atomism)." Grokipedia and Wikipedia, read 2026-09-27.
  7. Capra, F. (1975). The Tao of Physics. Shambhala.
  8. Aristotle. Physics IV.4 (place as the innermost boundary of the container).
  9. Vasubandhu. Viṃśikā, vv. 11–14 (the critique of partless atoms). Not re-read for this paper.
  10. Cousins, L.S. (2001). "On the Vibhajjavādins: The Mahiṃsāsaka, Dhammaguttaka, Kassapiya and Tambapaṇṇiya branches of the ancient Theriyas." Buddhist Studies Review 18(2): 131–182.
  11. Karunadasa, Y. (1967). Buddhist Analysis of Matter. Colombo: Department of Cultural Affairs. (Chs. 5 and 7 read for this revision.)
  12. Bodhi, Bhikkhu (gen. ed.) (1993). A Comprehensive Manual of Abhidhamma: The Abhidhammattha Sangaha of Ācariya Anuruddha. Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society.
  13. Nārada, U (Mūlapaṭṭhāna Sayadaw), assisted by Thein Nyun (1969). Conditional Relations (Paṭṭhāna), vol. I. Pali Text Society Translation Series 37. London: Luzac for the PTS.
  14. von Rospatt, A. (1995). The Buddhist Doctrine of Momentariness: A Survey of the Origins and Early Phase of this Doctrine up to Vasubandhu. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner. (Bibliographic record only; not reached.)
  15. Varzi, A. "Boundary." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (read 2026-09-28).
  16. Casati, R. & Varzi, A. (1999). Parts and Places: The Structures of Spatial Representation. MIT Press, ch. 5. (Cited through Varzi's survey; not read.)
  17. Ratnayaka, S. (1991). "Quantum physics foreshadowed in the Abhidhamma." Sri Lanka Journal of Buddhist Studies 3: 125–134. (Bibliographic record only; not read.)
  18. Visuddhimagga Mahāṭīkā (Paramatthamañjūsā), on Vism XI §346–349, e0103n.att.xml:6229–:6261.
  19. Sub-commentary on the Abhidhammāvatāra, on the eye-sensitivity, abh08t.nrf.xml:7373.
  20. Ledi Sayadaw. Paramatthadīpanī-anudīpanī, e0401n.nrf.xml:1261; colophon :1725–:1729.
  21. Rutherford, E. (1911). "The scattering of α and β particles by matter and the structure of the atom." Philosophical Magazine 21: 669–688. doi:10.1080/14786440508637080.
  22. Hofstadter, R. (1956). "Electron scattering and nuclear structure." Reviews of Modern Physics 28: 214–254. doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.28.214.
  23. Pohl, R. et al. (2010). "The size of the proton." Nature 466: 213–216. doi:10.1038/nature09250.
  24. ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL and SLD Collaborations et al. (2006). "Precision electroweak measurements on the Z resonance." Physics Reports 427: 257–454. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2005.12.006.
  25. The continuum bridge. Formal-abhidhamma run, 2026-10-14: SiliconWat/formal-abhidhamma, runs/2026-10-14-the-continuum-bridge/ (pre-registration, verbatim derivation and refuter, Bridge.lean), commit a964ee1.

Added at the 2026-11-14 revision

  1. Rovelli, C. (2009). "Forget time." arXiv:0903.3832. (Abstract only.)
  2. Bombelli, L., Henson, J. & Sorkin, R.D. (2006). "Discreteness without symmetry breaking: a theorem." arXiv:gr-qc/0605006. (Abstract only.)
  3. Rideout, D. & Wallden, P. (2009). "Emergence of spatial structure from causal sets." arXiv:0905.0017. (Abstract only.)
  4. Assanioussi, M., Lewandowski, J. & Mäkinen, I. (2017). "Time evolution in deparametrized models of loop quantum gravity." arXiv:1702.01688. (Abstract only.)
  5. Smolin, L. (2013). Time Reborn: From the Crisis in Physics to the Future of the Universe. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. (Cited through an encyclopedia summary; not read.)
  6. Paṭisambhidāmagga commentary, on the immediacy of consciousness, s0517a.att.xml:1709.

Sources checked at the 2026-11-14 revision

Each record was opened on 2026-11-14 before it was cited. The four arXiv records were fetched in a summarizing fetch that would not reproduce the abstracts verbatim; the paper therefore quotes none of them and states what each reports at the width the findings use (Rovelli: time should be dropped from a fundamental description; Bombelli, Henson and Sorkin: no equivariant measurable map from sprinklings to spacetime directions, even locally; Rideout and Wallden: a way to deduce spatial distances from a causal set, which handles timelike distances more easily; Assanioussi, Lewandowski and Mäkinen: a scalar or dust field as the time variable in deparametrized models). The Zakopane lectures (reference 11) were read in their text: the quotations of §5.4 are matched word for word, from §II.I and §V. The Pāli loci of §5.4's added bullet were each checked in the Chaṭṭha Saṅgāyana text at 05d5d3c against the quotation, with neighboring lines read.

Sources checked at the 2026-10-06 revision

Each record below was opened on 2026-10-06 before the work was cited or kept. Where a record lacked a detail the text uses, the detail was checked against a search index's summary that day and is marked so.